Welcome to The Fast Diet › The official Fast forums › Soul › Personal stories › Why isn’t it working for me?
This topic contains 8 replies, has 7 voices, and was last updated by dykask 2 years, 9 months ago.
Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)
1 May 18
I have been doing 5:2 for a month now and don’t think I’ve lost a single once? Ok I have probably been eating and drinking too much on non fast days but so many people do and still lose weight. I’m so disheartened I’ve done this diet before and it worked for me but what could I be doing wrong?
You’ve answered your own question in saying you are eating and drinking too much on non FDs. The only way to lose weight is to create a calorie deficit, so you need to be more disciplined on non FDs.
Try working out your TDEE using the resources tab. Use your goal weight and sedentary as exercise level. Then count calories for a week and you’ll soon see where you are going wrong.
Hi Lolabelle, you might feel encouraged, and have a laugh, by reading the top post here: https://thefastdiet.co.uk/forums/topic/really-no-weight-loss/
There must be something different between doing 5:2 now and doing it before. See if you can work out what it is. And work on eating healthy food, in sensible portions, on your non fast days. Make snacks a once=a-week treat if you can. If most non fast days are like that, you can afford a feast now and then.
Remember that 5:2 is meant to be a sustainable way of eating for long term health. I think it is fairly rare that it works as a short term weight loss technique, and it works best to lose weight slowly and keep it off, so hopefully 5:2 will allow you to do that.
Thank you Amazon and Cinque, both great replies, I am 49 female who doesn’t exercise like I used to and sadly still crave sugar when I am tired which is just deadly if you want to lose weight. My snack is usually a biscuit with a cup of tea and occasionally will have pudding if out for supper or lunch. I have never been able to count calories but I guess I need to do it on my non FD to find out why I am not losing weight. It took about a month the last time I did it so I shall keep going and hope the weight starts to come off. I want to lose about a stone so its not a huge amount but it needs to come off.
You can do it, Lolabelle. You know you can.
Do you eat on Fast Days or do a water-Fast?
If you have recipes for dinners <300 calories, try eating one of those on a non-Fast Day. That reduction in calories can make a difference. I’ve been Fasting for 5 years and have lots of recipes for Fast meals. Now that I’m maintaining, I can eat the things I want. But for me that does not include Fast Food and bagels because those things don’t appeal to me. I do eat cookies and cake and pie [in moderation] and drink wine. So you see, all these things will be possible once you reach your Target Weight.
2 May 18
Thank you fasting_me, so nice to have an encouraging response, a brilliant idea to have a dinner on NFD under 300 cals and I am going to do that today. I don’t eat fast food either but have too many snacks in the house for my kids. I will have to be much more careful of the food I eat on NFD if I want to lose the weight. Wow 5 years must be a a WOL for you – I do eat on FD but keep to 500 cals.
3 May 18
Lolabelle- I can sympathise with the sugar cravings & the food about in the house- I have 2 teenage boys who eat loads, there’s always stuff about & as they work funny hours too it feel like I’m always cooking something for them, so quite a challenge!
It is a pain but it’s definitely worth working out what calories you’re eating on nonFDs, using a tracker or writing it down. It’s surprising sometimes how things add up & you’ll undo the good you do on FDs. I also found that 2 FDs weren’t enough for me, I think I’ve messed up my metabolism over the years, so I did ADF or 3 FDs per week, & that worked (2 stone off). I also find that once I start eating, it’s harder to stop, it’s actually easier for me not to eat at all, so I just do liquid fasts now, or eat nothing until a small evening meal.
I know this forum is about 5:2, but I would add that I’d got into a bad habit of indulging too much on the sugary stuff on nonFDs, so have gone cold turkey & embraced keto (low carb, high fat), & that is really helping with losing my sweet tooth & cravings!
Good luck with your journey!
4 May 18
Lolabelle – the good thing about 5:2 is that it forces you to change what you eat on your regular days, otherwise you don’t lose the weight!
Perhaps think that your current way of eating, if you didn’t fast, is unhealthy as it makes you gain weight. Then find a new pattern of eating, that you like, that is proven to limit weight gain long term, such as the mediterranean diet or plant based eating.
The standard western diet makes 2/3rds of us overweight – most of us have to give it up if we want to be healthy. Not saying its easy and good luck finding your way forward – keep going and you will find it! 💪🍏🌱
5 May 18
Hi Lolabelle – I’m not so much into weight loss at this point, but I slowly reshaping my body, building muscle and cutting down the fat. The fasting helps with that and actually enforces me to think about the costs of what I eat. Over the last two years I’m finding my diet is changing and some of the changes are probably good for anyone, especially if you want to lose weight.
1) Avoid foods with added sugars. Natural sugar isn’t an issue, so fruit, vegetables and even diary or okay. Most processed foods are not. It isn’t you can’t eat them, but they should be more of a treat than a stable. Over time foods that have natural sugar in them start to taste sweet.
2) Add more high fiber foods to the diet. Beans, vegetables, whole grains like oatmeal, etc.
3) Eat slowly! Give your body time to tell you it is full.
4) Reduce snacking and especially try to give yourself 12 hours with no food on NFDs.
5) Experiment and keep making changes over time. This not only keeps it interesting but helps one learn about themselves.
If you exercise and you are more interested is losing weight, I think HIIT (High Intensity Interval Training) is better than cardio. These workouts can be brief, like even under 10 minutes. Push as hard as you can at something for 30 seconds. At that point you should be breathing so hard you can’t talk. Give yourself a couple minutes of rest or better yet light activity. Repeat 4 times. There are many variations. The problems with Cardio is that it takes a long time to be effective and then you are likely to lose some lean body mass too. However, I do both but now my cardio is more intense, like climbing 100 floors of stairs as quickly as I’m able. However, if you are in good shape, exercise may cause you to gain more weight than you lose.
Now I’m eating a lot even though I fast two days a week and that is why my weight loss is slow. I’m more interested in eating and building muscle than just losing weight. I typically eat around ~14000 calories a week and since I don’t eat while fasting that means I’m eating ~2800 calories/day (5 days a week.) It this point if I just cut down to 2000 calories/day I would probably lose 0.5kg/week. It is a trade off.
I’m finding I’m eating more whole plants – (vegetables & whole fruit) because I get to eat a LOT of then. (I need to get bigger plates to hold the salads!) I still eat diary, eggs and some meat. I also eat a lot of nuts and seeds which are very calorie dense. I eat regular food with my family, just not as much and when I can I pretty much eat a large almost vegan meal. (I’m not vegan, just like eating a lot!)
I don’t even really believe in eat less / move more, but at some point if one eats too much they don’t lose weight. I would guess you aren’t losing weight because a) you are eating too much of the wrong food and b) you are eating too much to lose the weight.
Over the last couple years I have had changes in my diet, mostly natural. 1) My consumption of things like ice cream has gone from once a day, to a few times a week and not more like a few times a month. 2) I used to drink a lot of diet soda and now I often don’t drink any in a week. Those could change at anytime as I’m always changing things in my diet, but the so far the changes have come naturally, I didn’t have to force them.
Good luck and I hope you figure out what works for you.
You must be logged in to reply.
Username or Email:
Track your weight and measurements, BMI and TDEE with our new tracker.
The Fast books are available throughout the world and in many different languages. Buy a copy today.
Michael is touring Australia this September! Here's a link to dates and tickets. Hope to see you there.
Michael Mosley gives an update for 2019, current research in the field and announces a tour starting in February.
Michael looks at the Horizon special, "What's the Right Diet for You" and tells us which diet they say is best for him.
• All featured posts •
in Welcome to The Fast Diet and Exercise forums • updated 14 minutes ago by Cinque
in Weight loss • updated 22 minutes ago by Aliev
in Weight loss • updated 5 hours, 57 minutes ago by Penz
• All recent topics •
Copyright © 2021 Michael Mosley and Mimi Spencer
Technical questions or problems with the site? Please email our technical contact.