How do I know it's doing me good?

Welcome to The Fast Diet The official Fast forums Body General health
How do I know it's doing me good?

This topic contains 3 replies, has 2 voices, and was last updated by  QuietOne 9 years, 8 months ago.

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)

  • Now age 65, I’ve been doing the 5:2 for over a year, not to lose weight but to achieve the supposed health benefits. I am lucky to have no particular health issues, normal BP, good weight, and am physically fit. I don’t find the regime particularly onerous but it would be nice to know whether/how I am benefiting from it. However, without paying for specialist tests of various sorts, I don’t see how I can find out whether this is anything more than a leap of faith! Trials on humans seem to be fairly thin on the ground so I suppose I just keep going for now, assuming that eventually there will be some hard evidence that, yes, intermittent fasting must have been doing me good even if I have no specific personal evidence. Any thoughts, anyone?

    Have you lost weight? Gained weight? Are your clothes looser? Have you had to buy new clothes or a new belt or both?

    Without some base line weight, measurements, ie. neck, chest, 1″ above the navel, hips, and thigh it’s tough to say if you have lost or not. Without blood work you don’t know if it’s doing you good or ill. I’d say a medical checkup at least once a year is needed.

    Do you keep a food journal and total calories daily? Are you eating under your TDEE? As you drop weight your BMI and TDEE will both drop. If you have a goal weight put that in the calculator and eat for the goal weight. You’ll reach it eventually and never have to go on a maintenance plan as you’re already there.

    If you feel better it’s probably doing you good. At our age (over 60) should have blood panels done at least once a year. Compare this to your last one. Your Doc should be able to tell you if the changes are good or bad.

    I started 5:2 for the benefits and those have been plenty went from pre-diabetic to low normal blood sugar, my COP is under control for the first time in over 11 years, my joint pain has decreased significantly, my use of pain meds aspirin, acetaminophen, other OTC pain reducers and prescription narcotics has dropped to levels unheard of for me. I’d say they are reduced OTC by 80% and prescription narcotics by 95%. My COPD rescue inhalers now last months instead of a week. The blood panels are fantastic and my Dr is a firm believer now though at the outset he said it couldn’t hurt he wasn’t a great fan.

    For me it’s been very obvious after only 3 months. Wight loss is a pure bonus Jan 1 236.8 pounds Today I weighed in at 196.8 pounds.

    I have to see my Doc once a month due to heart issues, hypertension etc Thank good for NWT health care and Seniors benefits. I get monthly checkups and everything is to the good so far. Knock on wood.

    I do wish that 5:2 wasn’t called a diet. It’s just a new way of eating.

    Thanks for your reply QuietOne. My point is that I have not lost weight, well perhaps a couple of pounds, because I don’t need to lose any and that was never my intention. I eat healthily, mostly the appropriate number of calories for my BMI (19.5), take regular exercise and have no health problems so I don’t actually feel any different or better nor do I have any evidence to show that the fasting regime is having any effect on my wellbeing. I know from what I have read that Human Growth Factor should increase and insulin resistance decrease with fasting but I don’t have evidence that that is happening to me unless I pay to have tests done and I don’t really want to spend money like that. So I guess I just have to keep believing that this must be benefiting me because others say it has had a positive effect on their health.

    To get the most effect from fasting, cell repair, inducing autophagy and autolysis doesn’t start until 18-24 hours into a fast from all I’ve read though some literature indicates 12 hours.

    Dr. Valter Longo recommends fasts of 2 to 5 days. If you have watched the video Eat, Fast, and Live Longer with Michael Mosley who basically started the 5:2 diet you will see him undergo a 3 day diet under Dr. Longo. A search will bring up multiple places to view the video

    I’ve tried fasts of 36 hours (basic 5:2 diet) to fasts that have extended to 7+ days. I do NOT suggest anyone try extended fasting without medical supervision and a complete health checkup first. Extended fasting can bring about some major emotional issues to some as well as physical issues that can be serious if you have any medical conditions.

    I honestly don’t know why anyone would want to fast longer than 7 days. I’ve read of water diets of 40 days and deaths of individuals under supervised care after 10 days. So a lot depends on the individual and the medical supervision and tests one receives to ensure the body is not in severe distress. You may want to stress your body with caloric restriction through fasting to achieve health benefits but I don’t think you want to distress your body to the point of death.

    For me 3 to 5 day fasts once a month are now part of my pattern. I will not recommend this to anyone else. The 5:2 diet as outlined does work for weight loss and some health benefits are derived from it. It is safe.

    To get maximum cellular level benefits it is likely that other methods are required.

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)

You must be logged in to reply.