Can you REALLY eat anything you want to on non-fast days? I gained 4 pounds.

This topic contains 8 replies, has 7 voices, and was last updated by mark82 2 weeks, 6 days ago.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)

ogdebhannes

5:09 pm
8 Apr 24
Permalink

Hello. I started my first fast day 4 days ago (Thursday). From Friday to Sunday I ate what I wanted. Not my normal diet though. I usually don’t eat fried foods or big sandwiches or pasta or ice cream. I had all of those and then some, plus a several cocktails on the week end. Results: a 4 pound gain. I actually expected that.

I read TheFastDiet. But maybe I misinterpreted what to eat on non fast days. They seemed to suggest that you can eat anything and still lose weight. But that approach does not work for me.

I would like some real guidance for eating on non fast days. What has been your experience?

AuroraMagic

12:29 am
10 Apr 24
Permalink

No you can’t just eat anything!
Basically the way I read it from any of the books is you increase the daily intake from from 800 cals & 5g fat to 1000cals/ 20g fat, on the nonfast days.

Cinque

12:42 am
10 Apr 24
Permalink

I am glad it only took you one week to realise that eating high calories from fat sugar and alcohol led to weight gain. Lesson learnt!

The current recommendation from Dr Mosley is to follow Mediterranean diet guidelines.

funshipfreddie

6:39 am
10 Apr 24
Permalink

@ogdebhannes – just be sensible on non-fast days. Remember, eating ‘whatever we like’ is how we all finished up here. There’s no magic bullet. Counting calories on non-fast days might help you to reach your goal. Stick to your Total Daily Energy Expenditure (TDEE) on the days you’re not fasting. There’s a calculator on this site, & plenty of apps to make the calorie-counting relatively painless.

ogdebhannes

8:59 pm
10 Apr 24
Permalink

Thanks for clarifying this. I’m still fasting but eating more sensibly. I appreciate all of the tips 🙂

lkdalyvb

9:35 pm
12 May 24
Permalink

I’m a Newby! Do I restrict eating hours on non-fasting days? Should eating be restricted to an 8 hour period or not with the 5:2 program?

Jabbathehut

8:21 am
1 Jul 24
Permalink

This is the first time in my life I’ve had to diet ,I started on Slimming World but it was too restrictive ,very little bread allowed and daily milk intake restricted to 300mls ,even though I use skimmed .

on a whim after our weekly meal out ,1 course only ,but wine included,I woke and thought I’d try a fast day after reading the 5:2 diet book ,it didn’t seem too difficult for a 1st ever fast ,had lean ham ,low-fat yoghurts ,boiled eggs,but then I had been well sated the night before.

Any tips please on foods for fast days?

mark82

10:12 am
15 Nov 24
Permalink

While non-fast days give you more freedom, it’s still simple to overeat, particularly if you don’t pay close attention to portion sizes. It’s normal to gain a few pounds, but moderation and balance can help you keep your progress while still indulging in your favorite foods!