Welcome to The Fast Diet › The official Fast forums › Body › Different approaches to intermittent fasting › Alternate Day Fasting (a journal that invites participants)
This topic contains 21 replies, has 8 voices, and was last updated by c702 9 months, 2 weeks ago.
Viewing 23 posts - 1 through 23 (of 23 total)
26 Jun 17
So I’m on a new journey to, weight loss, health and the Alternate style of fasting. My goal is 40 pounds. I will be aiming at (0 to 600) calories on the fasting days and low carb for the feasting days. My window for the eating will be anywhere from (1 to 6) hours each day starting at somewhere around dinner. So that can remain a flexible opening time for life situations that always happen. Out with friend to eat…. ect.
If you’ve been wanting to attempt this style of fasting please feel free to join me. We can root one another on…….and be Finally There……
4 Jul 17
Well I’m checking in after one week. Basically I did good and bad all week with this woe, so My weight is the same as when I started…
Today I’m on a DD. bonebroth with a can of turkey and one brazil nut for today at about 400 calories.
I had a similar experience when I tried to do an AD fasting approach. The non-fast days were the problem – I couldn’t seem to stop myself eating too many calories on the NFDs. In effect the FDs and NFDs ended up cancelling each other out. I think that for someone with a high TDEE this might be less of a problem as they would accrue a huge calorie deficit on their FDs that would be difficult to counteract on the NFDs. Unfortunately I have a low TDEE of just 1400 calories. I found that it was all too easy to eat enough extra calories on the NFDs to balance out the small calorie deficit I’d accrued on FDs. (Basically 500 on FDs and 2300 on NFDs is maintenance for me.)
After a bit of trial and error, experimenting with AD, 4:3 and 5:2, I found that I need a minimum of 2 NFD between FDs if I’m to have any hope of not bingeing on every NFD. If I do that, the binging is occasional not regular. In the end I settled on a 3 day pattern of 1FD+2NFD. Over time this gives you a few more FDs than 5:2 but if feels pretty much the same as the gap between FDs on 5:2 is often also 2 NFDs. Like you, I also used an eating window. I stick to an eating window of roughly 16:8 every day. For me this means restricting my food intake to approx 11am-7pm, although it will vary by an hour occasionally. Although this doesn’t prevent me from binge eating on NFDs it does limit the damage I can do – especially as snacking in the evening was traditionally a problem for me.
I would suggest that you try another week on AD if you want to, but it you find your weight isn’t shifting then try something different. AD is challenging to commit to, and I think it’s only worth the difficultly if you get good results.
I hope next week is better for you.
15 Jul 17
thanks for the encouragement LJoyce,
I’m on day two of a water fast right now that I hope last for 5 days. I’m thinking this will help get better squared away for the ADFing. I hear the autophahy doubles at the 5 day marker and I could use some of that too.
16 Jul 17
The main problem I have with both alternate day fasting or FD + 2 NFDs is social. I’ve had to work at it to keep my fasting from interfering too much with family. If the fasting day is always changing that becomes a difficulty.
Also to curve the binge eating you might try eating really slowly and truly enjoying each byte or nibble to the maximum. For me it requires a very mindful approach, but I’m eating a few hundred less calories a day when I do it.
Social can be a problem, but I’ve decided to not fast on social events and then just work around them.
It is a great time right now for me to fast with the hot summer and the husband working a lot of hours, so I’m taking advantage of it.
Right now I am finishing up day 2 of a total water, coffee, tea only fast that will hopefully last for 5 days. I believe I will have a lot more control over the eating days, but we will see. I will try the eating slow idea. I certainly can wolf food down when I’m in the mood. LOL!
@finallythere – I hope you make through the second day. I find day 2 the hardest and after that it gets easy, at least for me. However my longest fast is only 86 hours, far short of your 5 day goal.
I hope you make it!
Thanks for the encouragement Dykask,
Well I didn’t make it the 5 days, but I did make it 48 hours, and broke it with keto food, but really wanted carbs. So I’ll call it a victory!
I ate at 5:30 and will have another meal at dinner then start the next fasting round. Wednesday and Thursday I have family over so I’ll just try and make it till we start the eating on Wednesday. I feel more confident now, but I Know I need to stay away from the foods that trigger cravings. Man, that is a Big food group!
What are you doing Dykask?
17 Jul 17
FinallyThere, I hit the wall on a couple of my early B2B fasts (just last month). Once towards the end of the 3rd day, once towards the end of the 2nd day. I got to a point where I knew I had to eat something, so I did.
Now I’m breezing through 3 day fasts (on 600 calories per day). I’m trying to stay low-carb on my NFDs, which I’m sure is helping.
There are a few members who are doing 4:3, which is almost alternate-day fasting. I’m going to try and fast for half the days this month, but mostly in blocks of 2 or 3 days at a time.
18 Jul 17
Hi big Bill,
well I did make 48 hours and then did a 24 hour non fasting day. I stayed low carb but the weigh in this morning was the same as before I started the 48 hours. I need to start my tracking log.
So far since starting I’ve gone down 3 to 5 pounds. I’m now managing 0 calories for the fasting days. I’m attempting to do what Dr. Fung says, when you fast,,,,fast and when you feast,,,,feast. Well Now I’m doing that, but I think I need to moderate that feasting part. I’m to darn good at that!
I did 5 day fasts last year about once every 8 weeks. Had to stop early this year because of an unrelated health issue.
It took me a few tries before I made it to 5 days, so if you’re only getting to 3 days keep trying and you may make it to 5. My experience was on the 5th day I wasn’t really hungry, but had no energy.
19 Jul 17
@finallythere, with this way of eating you are unlikely to See consistent and steady weight loss.
I’ve had 3 day fasts where the scales haven’t budged, and weekends where I’ve overeaten including chocolate and KFC and lost half a kilo.
It’s better to take a long-term view. Try to do the right things, and if the scales show a loss from one month to the next you are on the right track. Don’t worry about whether the scales accurately reflect what you’ve been doing over the previous few days – because the chances are that they won’t.
Thanks for the insight Bill,,,,3 days no loss and chicken and chocolate a loss is well,,,,hmmmmm! Not what you’d think would happen.
I will stay the course. I have seen all these youtubes with outrageous losses and hope for the same.
Made it for 37 hours ended fast with a 3 hour eating window and ate only 1500 calories,,,Full!
well this morning had 300 calories. I’m on a nonfasting day and the scale showed another pound gone. Woo Hoo! 6 total since start! That first week did nothing, but now things are moving. I do know I was eating enough to undo my fasting progress.
I just checked the amount of calories a 140 pound person at 5’6″ should weigh,,,,,Wow 1,950 to 2,150,,,,really? Sweet! I can do that easy,,,,,,
So the more I research the fast ADF and extended fast, I know this is my path to the right weight and Health. I hope to actually make the 5 day fast soon. After family leaves I’ll be back at it. It appears it is best as far as the body healing itself to lay off the heavy exercise that would cause the body to redirect its healing effort to healing the muscle tissue you just broke down. So On those days I’ll just chill and read and do the least I can to allow healing.
21 Jul 17
FinallyThere, I’m sure it was just water weight that I’d been holding onto while fasting. Chocolate and KFC certainly wouldn’t have made me shed any fat. It seems like I’m holding onto water weight while fasting then dropping it when I come off the fast.
I don’t think I have enough discipline for alternate day fasting. One of the things that gets me through my fasting days is knowing that I can drop the fast if I feel like it and eat whatever I am craving. And just start again the next day. That’s what is working for me so far about intermittent fasting, not being locked into a limited range of foods or any sort of diet schedule.
I certainly do want to do the 5 day fast ever now and then and use the ADF as a default setting.
I will try another attempt at it but first I think just making the 3 day would be great. I’m going to try and do that this sunday to Wednesday.
I have heard the longer fast can bring healing to the body. I’m for that!
It could be water Big Bill or other things that store in our bodies perhaps a little longer than we like on fast.
I understand about the freedom you seek with just going for fasts as you want to and eating what you want.
Basically I’m going to be loose with the ADF and throw in some longer fast, so about the same, but keeping ADF as my default so I don’t sway off the path too far
25 Jul 17
Well here I am again. Just reached 175 and it is nice to be here again, except for the fact that I was here on Thursday last week and ate like a pig that day and gained 5 pounds back and it took fri. Saturday, sunday and Monday of OMAD to take those pounds back off.
I haven’t been ADFing lately but will work into that. I just want to stabilize at OMAD for a while. Starting Wed. we are on a week vacation and that would fit in the best.
2 Aug 17
I’ve recently switched from 24 hour fasting 2x per week to 36 hours alternate day (M/W/F) and already I find this kind of fast so much easier. Eating for me is like an on/off switch, so if I consume nothing it’s easier to maintain. Knowing I can eat at some point in the day just makes me hungry.
I fast in the pure sense – coffee, water and if I’m low on salt I have a cup of Bovril, but that’s it.
I find fasting really easy to work around social events, I just have to be flexible. Some weeks I’ll do three fasts, some weeks I’ll only be able to do two. Plus, nothing helps you recover from a massive night out on the lash like a good fast!
I do eat a lot on my feed days, I just advise to listen to your body. I hate going to bed feeling so full that I’m uncomfortable, so on feed days I stick to lots of proteins and fats mostly (but I do still eat carbs because OMG TOAST) and that fills me up without the uncomfortable over-eaten feeling. Avoiding heavy processed food, as recommended above, is spot on, though. If I have something sugary on a feed day I will not stop jonesing for sugar for the rest of the day. I tend to have a dessert treat after my final meal of the day to stop that.
3 Aug 17
Thank for the post. I’m trying a longer fast this week to help my body heal. Supposedly the autophagy will do that. I’m aiming for 7 days but anywhere in that area will do.
I’ve found I need a lot more veggies to keep my colon good. Sorry for the TMI. But I also want to try and redirect my eating habits out of the night zone. That is most likely one of my biggest downfalls when dieting.
Then I’ll go back to the ADF, or maybe just 18/6 for the refeed and then back into the ADF. This is all a big work in progress. I’ve decided to do mainly soup and salad for the refeed days. I’m on day one,,,,six more to go…..
I also fast in the pure sense. That will help with the HGH.
On day three of the 7 day fast and feeling confident I will do it. We have a dinner date for Sunday this week, but I’m gonna ask the friends if we can just do coffee. Basically I need this fast and am pumped about it.
I’ve been soaking info on autophagy and will follow the advice of the experts. Supposedly the reefed is just as important and the fast. The fast will kill off weak cells and the feeding time right after will replenish. I need to see how long is best for the refeeding time before I go into the ADF.
This 7 day fast will help me to stay more true to the ADF, but my adjusted plan is to eat AIP for the my feasting times in order to make sure all systems go,,,,(when I need them to) Basically I don’t think the keto was working for me in the potty department. I probably wasn’t eating enough fat and too much meat. To hard to balance for me. So I’m just going to eat the Autoimmune Protocol Paleo and that should be fine.
9 Aug 17
Leia1979 can you explain how you are eating? I’m not eating breakfast on my coffee until noon or 1. Then I eat salad with chicken and something healthy for dinner. This is a non fast day! On a fast day I skip food from a 7pm until a 7pm next day. I do 2 to 3 fast days per week. While I was also skipping breakfast on non fast st days. I think I was breaking the fast above the 500.
Would love to know what you do and how your progesss has been going. 😉
8 Sep 17
I’m working my way up to long fasts and trying to kill my appetite and shed the pounds quickly. I’ve heard of people as overweight as me managing 30+ days fasts but the risks of that seem quite crazy. I’ve just done a 24 hour fast and I’ve had a 1200 calorie meal at the end now I’m not eating for 38 hours (sunday lunchtime) as my next meal which will be about 900 calories (sunday lunch). Just to see what happens. Hoping to lose 2 pounds of fat since the days have been active ones.
I’d like my default to be alternate days since I have 80+ pounds to lose.
You must be logged in to reply.
Username or Email:
Track your weight and measurements, BMI and TDEE with our new tracker.
The Fast books are available throughout the world and in many different languages. Buy a copy today.
Michael looks at the Horizon special, "What's the Right Diet for You" and tells us which diet they say is best for him.
Results from our tracker show that the average weight lost over the first three months on The Fast Diet is 5-6 kgs (11 to 13 lbs).
Michael Mosley posts a handy graphic to help avoid hidden sugars in food.
• All featured posts •
in Weight loss • updated 8 minutes ago by Diana123
in Welcome to The Fast Diet and Exercise forums • updated 15 minutes ago by Diana123
in Weight loss • updated 49 minutes ago by Brads27
• All recent topics •
Really enjoyed doing this interview. Richard Fidler very thoughtful https://t.co/beLeGCmEcG
Reply | Retweet | Favorite
posted at 1:02 AM on 20 Jun 2018
I think prevention will be key for those genetically at risk. In my book Clever Guts I go into why auto immune dise… https://t.co/9H8XjcXL1T
posted at 1:01 AM on 20 Jun 2018
Oddly the hunger goes after first couple of days. Research shows suppression of hunger hormones https://t.co/Fl63CSjffh
posted at 12:57 AM on 20 Jun 2018
Copyright © 2018 Michael Mosley and Mimi Spencer
Technical questions or problems with the site? Please email our technical contact.