Welcome to The Fast Diet › The official Fast forums › Body › Weight maintenance › 5:2 diet and low-carb diet combined
This topic contains 9 replies, has 6 voices, and was last updated by Coda 4 years, 5 months ago.
Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)
17 Dec 14
Hi there – I’ve just joined this forum and have only read a few posts, but some seemed to be concerned with the disappointment people were feeling over negligible weight loss. My experience has been this: I started doing the Cura Romana diet a couple of years ago – it’s a very low-carb diet which includes an elimination part, so you get to know which foods agree with you and which don’t. This was really useful for me and I felt GREAT (never got a cold and my asthma cleared up) and lost about a stone. However, it’s REALLY hard to stick to because you can’t go out for a meal at a restaurant or at someone’s house without feeling like a neurotic weirdo who needs special catering. So what I’ve done (mostly) is to combine what I learnt from Cura Romana with the fasting diet. So I do my fasting on 2 days and on the other 5 try to stick to the foods that I know are good for me, but I don’t limit them. Also, I feel I can go out for the occasional meal and indulge myself without feeling guilty. Anyway, I was putting on weight for a while after starting the 5:2 (which was disappointing) but now, after 6 months or so, I feel that my weight has evened out – fewer fluctuations – and I’m feeling comfortable in my clothes. I don’t actually weigh myself regularly, but can tell by how I look in the mirror and by how my clothes fit, that this is working for me.
So maybe the low-carb thing works in conjunction with the 5:2 – just an idea for people who are having difficulty shedding weight.
And did anyone else have the experience of it happening really slowly for them at first, then seeming to be able to stick at an ideal size after 6 months or so?
I’m 50, by the way, and battling with all the usual peri-menopausal, mid-life issues!!
19 Feb 15
Hi – I very much agree with you. I’m a similar age and also short and female – it’s quite hard to lose much weight on the 5:2, and although I think I’d be happy with my ½ – 3/4 lb weekly loss long term, I’d like to see more of an initial impact.
I’m trying a few things. The first being low carb (or more or less so) as you suggest. The second is to do an extra day a week where I can – I don’t find this much of a hardship if it’s just an ordinary night in, to be honest. And the final thing, a real plus for the 5:2, is that I am finding that my appetite is smaller, and that I quite enjoy the feeling of being more empty and hungry, so that my food intake on other days naturally diminishes.
1 Nov 16
Hi I’ve been doing 5 2 plus low carb on none fast day, been doing it for 3 weeks with disappointing results. I think I’m getting somewhere then the scales go down then up again. I do feel a lot better though & I feel that I’ve lost belt fat.The added problem I have is I no longer have a thyroid as it was very over active & stuck out (goiter). Does anyone have experiences of 5 2 without a thyroid it would be good to get some advice.
28 Nov 16
Hi, I’m also interested in this topic. Firstly, Fyness are you on some thyroid replacement hormone? It used to be called Thyroxin. Maybe the name has changed.
I’ve been on the 5:2 for over a year now. Initially I lost 10 kilos. After six or seven months this weight loss slowed right down. Long story short, I got disheartened and stopped the ..FD. I soon started to gain weight again rapidly. I’ve now started the FD again but weight loss was slow so I’ve changed to a low carb diet. I’ve lost a kilo in one week, feel full of energy and my blood pressure has gone down too. I personally find it difficult to combine the two ie. counting calories as well as carbs.
29 Nov 16
You don’t need to go low carb as such. Just get your carbs from veggies and some fruit. Avoid sugar and ALL grain based foods. No rice, bread, pasta, cereals etc. Your glucose spikes will plummet and your insulin will plummet. 202 lbs down to 153 lbs, now in maintenance mode 6:1. No grains pass my lips.
@bigbooty – can I ask you something – I believe you have suggested before (in another thread) to obtain a blood glucose meter. Can I ask if you recommend any particular one and do they all require you to prick a finger? That is the only thing that puts me off – is is sore? Also would this be for any one wishing to be in fat burning mode or maybe just for someone with possible type 2 diabetes? Thanks
I use a Freestyle Optium Neo (readily available on ebay or most diabetic stores) as it is one of the few meters that can measure blood glucose and ketone bodies (basically tells you when you have entered true fat burning mode). Toughen up princess. ha ha ha. Its really not that big a deal. You get an auto lancet with the meter to prick yourself with, its over so quickly its really not an issue.
Obviously if you are diabetic you really need to use it but anyone can use it to monitor their blood glucose condition. I initially used it to see my reaction to different foods. I would measure my BG before I ate something and then after eating that food I would measure every 30 minutes to see my response. Orange juice just spikes BG through the roof. Processed grains are also pretty bad.
You insert a different “stick” into the meter to measure ketones. They are a bit pricey but you can pick them up for about 60 cents per stick. I usually buy them off ebay when someone has them on special. I use this to monitor when I enter ketosis. When I first started doing 5:2 it would take me 48-60 hours to enter ketosis (fat burning). It now takes me 24 hours. Most people take ketosis as being when you get a reading of 0.5 mmol/L. Since Im only doing one fast day now Im usually between 0.5-1.2 mmol/L I used to get to about 2mmol/L when fasting for two consecutive days. You want to stay below 3mmol/L otherwise you start going too acidic. Important to drink lots and you find that you tend to go to the toilet more often when in ketosis. Its your bodies way of regulating the acidity. You burn fat all the time, its just that when you enter ketosis the vast majority of your energy is coming from fat burning with very little from glucose metabolism.
Im not really a low carb person, I just get most of my carbs from veggies. I only enter ketosis when I water fast. Im a scientist by occupation so I like to measure things.
Hi thanks BB maybe I’ll give it a go if I toughen up ha ha – it would be nice to know what is going on. I read that a certain degree of ketosis can cause liver problems and there is a level to attain but not beyond but not sure if this is true? Or is this what you mean by getting too acidic? I obviously want to be in the best fat burning mode. Thanks again
@coda. Im the biggest wimp there is. My wife always looks after the kids when they cuts and need bandages etc. If I can use a lancet anyone can. really its not a big deal.
I think what you are referring to is ketoacidosis. Usually this is not a problem unless you are a diabetic, in VERY poor health, or have suffered some sort of illness that has compromised your liver/pancreas/kidney etc. You really want your ketones to be below 3 mmol/L and your body does a pretty good job in regulating this. The highest I ever got was about 2.4mmol/L and that is after 60 hours of water only fasting. You tend to urinate more often while in ketosis and this is the body’s mechanism in controlling the acidity. So make sure you drink lots. You also want to lower your blood glucose levels so that they are in the range 3.9-5.9 mmol/L. The lower the better. You are ALWAYS burning fat regardless of what you eat or your physical activity, but that percentage goes up and down. The closer you get your blood glucose down to 3.9 mmol/L the better off you are with respect to increasing the fat burning percentage. In all the time Ive been monitoring my BG (over a year now I have only ever dipped below 3.9 once and that was 3.8). Most of the time my BG in the morning after just waking up is in the low 4s. if I eat bread or some other processed carb the night before my BG will be low 5s. The lasting impact is that BIG.
Im not low carb as such, Im low processed grain carbs. carbs locked up in fibre are not a problem.
With regards to physical activity if you can get your heart rate up to about 60-65% then you burn the most amount of fat for that given activity. 60-60% is something like a slow jog or a fast walk. You should still be able to have a conversation, but only just. If you can talk with ease youre not pushing hard enough. If you cant talk then your pushing too hard.
Thank you, certainly food for thought lol.
You must be logged in to reply.
Username or Email:
Track your weight and measurements, BMI and TDEE with our new tracker.
The Fast books are available throughout the world and in many different languages. Buy a copy today.
Michael is touring Australia this September! Here's a link to dates and tickets. Hope to see you there.
Michael Mosley gives an update for 2019, current research in the field and announces a tour starting in February.
Michael looks at the Horizon special, "What's the Right Diet for You" and tells us which diet they say is best for him.
• All featured posts •
in Weight loss • updated 3 hours, 59 minutes ago by symba7
in Weight loss • updated 4 hours, 5 minutes ago by travis8083
in Welcome to The Fast Diet and Exercise forums • updated 6 hours, 35 minutes ago by thinatlast
• All recent topics •
Copyright © 2021 Michael Mosley and Mimi Spencer
Technical questions or problems with the site? Please email our technical contact.