I am a binger – any info on fasting and bingeing

Welcome to The Fast Diet The official Fast forums Body Science of intermittent fasting
I am a binger – any info on fasting and bingeing

This topic contains 3,042 replies, has 111 voices, and was last updated by  Delayedgratification 5 years, 4 months ago.

Viewing 50 posts - 2,651 through 2,700 (of 3,046 total)

  • Hi Queen,
    I was quite resistant to making anymore changes to my diet. I had stopped sugar in my tea, stopped buying chocolate every day, eating cakes and puddings on a daily basis and swopping from white pasta and rice to the wholemeal variety was enough of a change as we already ate wholemeal bread. I like avocado and was happy to mash one and spread it over a couple of slices of toast for lunch. I like to eat nuts and fish, so thought that I was doing OK in terms of my diet being healthy.

    There were several folk in this forum who were encouraging others to stop eating bread/rice/pasta/pasta etc completely and I thought that they were unhinged. I had a look at LCHF which all looked rather healthy and balanced. I also had a look at Jason Fung on You Tube as well, and he inspired me further to see the benefits of fasting.

    So, I thought that I would conduct my own little, one person experiment. It is simply that some days I will have half my meals for the day without any rice/pasta/potatoes/bread and some days I will have none at all and see how I get on. Will I be hungry? Do I feel better? Do I get the sugar crash? What will I eat?

    Yesterday, I had the nut/seed mixture for breakfast with homemade full fat milk turned into yoghurt. Lunch was 100g smoked salmon with 2 eggs scrambled in some butter followed by some fruit. My son was home for dinner and had requested a homemade curry with rice which we both enjoyed and both left some rice. I felt very sleepy afterwards and it was a struggle to stay awake. Today, it is more of the same for breakfast and lunch will be the rest of the salmon with salad and dressing(virgin olive oil/white wine vinegar and mustard-yum). Dinner will be lamb chops, new potatoes(in the fridge and need using up) and vegetables. Tomorrow is a FD and I will have nothing after the meal this evening until lunchtime at the very earliest but I will try to push it into the afternoon or even until dinnet time when my son will be home for dinner when he will have steak and I will have fish and we shall both have salad.

    I eat a lot of fish and salad and vegetables. I feel much better when I do too. It all goes downhill when I have something with sugar in and then I am like a heat-seeking missile searching for more and more. But if you think about it, food manufacturers manipulate our biology so that we snack and eat more of their products..and make them more profits.

    Yesterday, I was out and about and decided that I would have an Almond Croissant on a once a week treat. It was lovely and I thoroughly enjoyed it but I was then looking for my next fix. If the ice cream van had been where it usually is, then I would have had one on my way home too. This is something that I usually walk past( I love ice cream)without much trouble as I know what happens.

    My lunches don’t feature any bread or pasta or rice or potatoes and they are lovely and filling. Have your salmon with salad or vegetables. I do and try salmon brushed with full fat mayonnaise with parmesan and a few breadcrumbs sprinkled over the top-just a few!. It is just practice and you will get used to it and then will not feel deprived.

    My challenge is to have either all of your lunches or evening meals without bread/pasta/rice or potatoes this week. Are you up for it?

    The more I read, the more that I am convinced that we have

    all been brainwashed into thinking that we need these carbohydrates at every meal and that fat is bad for us. More and more doctors are talking about the benefits of fruit/veg/nuts/olive oil/butter to our cardiac as well as general health. A Mediterranean diet is one with lots of oily fish, but no pasta or pizza!

    I am a convert. Try it for a week and see how you feel without the processed crap. You will feel better and stop eating the oatcakes/biscuits as they won’t be in the house. The kids don’t need them and neither do you.

    I wish that I had known this years ago. But now that I do I have managed to get my overweight son(who has Aspergers) on board and he is losing weight too.

    Hi all,

    Saludos from a sunny UK (for once)

    Hi Queen, nice to see you. I agree with you abut the long windows, I have no breakfast but have coffee with cream on some days, (too many probably) and that keeps me going for a loooooooong time. Yes the LCHF isn’t for me as a binger, as I can overeat on it, so I best to steer clear of items like butter which sometimes lead to me buying bread just so I can ‘use the butter’. I’m also not good with peanut butter, so that’s out. I’m better with cheese. I think I lurk between low carb and meditteranean, happy with that.

    Since I got the Vit D deficiency I’ve been more mindful about making food count. I’m not sure of the cause but it could be that since I did my knee in I’ve stopped running, ergo less time in the fresh air, although I do ‘walk’ my running route. It could be just an age thing, more likely the older you get. One great thing is I’ve finally got my physio appointment (6 months later) so may be back running soon.

    Annette, I like the sound of you plan! is the Krav Maga a contact martial art? sounds cool.

    Jade, I also made the cauliflower pizza, I haven’t got a microwave though so briefly cooked the rice cauliflower, so ended up quite soggy, do you or CaliB know anyway around this? Is the microwaving supposed to reduce the sogginess? It tasted pretty fab anyway, and I put anchovies, red peppers and Chipotle on top. Well done on your maintenance and rule book ๐Ÿ™‚

    On the topic of bodies, the pressure girls and women are put under makes me rage. We are often solely judged on our looks/bodies and if we’re ‘hot’ or not. I think the nicer aspect of arriving at 50, is you begin to see how ludicrous it is and appreciate having a healthy body that’s supported you so far! When we had our new UK prime minister, the newspapers covered, wait for it, her ‘kitten’ heels. It has changed a bit, but not enough, and it’s sad that young girls (and some boys) are bombarded with impossible expectations. It’s something we’re all familiar with. The 5:2 could have had more of an emphasis on exercise, I find HITT deathly boring, It could have emphasized ALL the fabulous activities we can do to find our “fit”. I read the other day that office workers are more prone to illnesses etc.. due to sitting all day, and it’s crucial to walk more and keep moving. Rant over..

    Spring, yes add stress to the mix and I’m likely to fail ๐Ÿ™ I loved the thought of your G n T’s, I might join you in October when the 100 day challenge ends! it’s not been that tough but I will enjoy a large glass of Malbec or Pinot at the end, the healthier grapes. I’m not sure I want to keep on drinking after, I will see. I drank (honestly ;-)) approx 14 units a week (6 x 175ml glass) and that would be over limit at ‘celebratory times’ so what seemed like ‘I don’t drink much’ was a bit more. On the other hand, life’s short, and I wasn’t generally over the limit, but over the years it takes it toll. I don’t expect to lose weight, just by ditching the booze, but never say never..

    T xx

    A convert! Welcome to the Unhinged, annette. ๐Ÿ˜€

    I find that the best teacher is experience, and controlled experimentation allowed me to create my own best plan. I’m delighted to see that this is working for you, too.

    Great challenge, Annette – Queen, I’d recommend doing LCHF until dinner, then include some fruit or if desperate whole grains along with meat-veg. There was a diet years ago that was a version of this – you ate very lowcarb during the day, then had an evening meal that could include anything you liked, the idea being that keeping it LC during the day would keep the cravings at bay. Didn’t work for me because of course feeding the sugar monster at night just woke him back up again. So, I’ve finally gotten it thru my thick head that I don’t need many carbs and certainly not the junky sugary ones. Not only “don’t need” but should actively avoid, though I’m at a point where I realize I can relax now and then. But it’s rather like doing anything else stupid but fun – figure out how much you can get away with without getting hurt. A bit like drinking whiskey๐Ÿ˜‰ – some shouldn’t at all, others can have a nice nip and walk away relatively unscathed. Life is a constant risk-benefit analysis, when you think about it.

    Tango, I agree wholeheartedly re exercise, that it “doesn’t help with weight loss” can be a bit confusing. Its benefits are much like fasting’s benefits; even if you eat all the calories back you get cardio/health, mobility, and those wondrous endorphin benefits. It’s always a mood elevator for me. Dancing must surely do that for youโ˜บ๏ธ

    Speaking of which, I ordered a brace for my back and it feels great. I’m happy to think that I’ll hike, perhaps even jog a bit, without pain. Taking it slow and easy, just walking for now๐Ÿ˜‡but must have my fresh air and a few endorphins. Planning dinner out tonight so I’m considering a fast till then, just coffee with a bit of cream boy do I love that. Take care everyone, stay strong, the road may be long but it does lead somewhere๐Ÿ›ฃ Lolly, extra hugs to you for health issues; so grateful you are an islander, a sage and calm influence for me.๐Ÿ’›๐Ÿ”†๐ŸŒดxxx

    oops we crossed posts Annette..

    Hi,

    Annette, thanks again for your relentless support (and jade and the team!). I think like tango I have the ability to overeat in times of stress and that could be packs of ready cooked salmon, mascarpone or bread (while loaves!). What I do notice is, if I do binge on protein veggies food stuffs I don’t get quite the same out of control feeling as carbs, but then I don’t know if it’s low mood making me crave carbs and therefore the serotonin. There are times in not fussed by bread but other times the euphoric feeling can’t compete with anything! So it must be doing something chemically.

    Interestingly with low carb, I have seen a hormone specialist due to terrible pmt and she took my testosterone (which was 0!) and oestrogen levels which are declining, so am supplementing with oestrogen. However, she said I should really be going low carb because she says the insulin release from carbs is affecting levels of oestrogen and she says I would be much better off going low carb. So it’s worth a try.

    Jade your suggestion would make sense to me as I can’t really sleep if in ketosis, I have no idea why although I guess carbs make you sleepy? Years ago I was very slim but I suppose I was pretty low carb. I actively just didn’t keep bread cereals in the house as I knew I overage on them, sure I had sandwich if I was out, but didn’t bother otherwise. However, I have rarely been free of bouts of bingeing.

    I do look at the calendar and always my biggest lizard brain like binges have been mostly, the week before my monthly ailment (!) or after a night of no sleep or before an interview or a social occasion that I’m anxious about.

    What I am scared of is going high fat then changing my mind half way through a stressful day then going to full on binge too! I added olive oil to my daily diet some time ago (without omitting anything else!!) and obviously gained weight.

    I actually find things like buffets and family time a nightmare as I get a little stressed and constant food everywhere. Ofcourse it’s gluttony but sometimes bingeing feels like something else, an excessive drive/ urge to keep eating. I actually don’t enjoy it, and the more I have the more I want. I know people say addiction doesn’t exist but even things like multigrain bread or oatcakes, I start eating and just want more. It must be, to some extent genetic because we just don’t have sweets in the house now as my child wanted more and more, yet when we have had other children stay some want more and more but others are satisfied with just one or two.

    I think about how my friend will say, “I really want a cigarette” or my husband will say “i really find it hard to say no to a beer” or “I need a drink” I feel exactly that way about food at times. It’s not all the time but usually hormone driven/ stress triggered. I actually find it helpful to remind myself it’s a bit of a problem, to term is as a potential addiction ie remind myself of those foods are there I will probably overeat them, so to think ahead. Those two weeks prior to the monthly ailment is a killer though, it was bad in my teens and seems to be bad again later in life… Twenties were fine, and early thirties… Sigh!

    Hi Bingeing Queen,

    Yes, there is a type of food “addiction”. I have it. I spent months with a dietician doing a full elimination testing regime to work out which foods it was. It is a type of food intolerance, where the reaction to the food is not a rash, or pains in the stomach, or diarhea, or constipation, but a feeling of addiction. The reaction to the food is delayed. It works like this –

    Eat the food – initial response is to feel good – some time later (for me it’s 2hrs) the bad reaction (withdrawal) sets in – this bad reaction also creates an addictive need or addictive compulsion to eat the food again – when it’s eaten the bad reaction goes away so the person feels better or good – some time later withdrawal begins ipand compulsion begins again. And so on. There may be other bad reactions to the food as well as the delayed withdrawal response. The withdrawal and reaction can include mood, cognitive and emotional changes.

    If I eat ANY of the foods I react to in this way it triggers an addictive compulsion to ALL of the foods I react to in this way. It is very destructive.

    I discovered going through my extended time with a hospital dietician that I react to all grains except corn, in this way. Even rice if I have more than a very small amount, say 2 tbspns or a couple of rice crackers. Also a no-no are things like chia seeds, buckwheat, spelt, millet, triticale. Also on my addictive list is sugar. When I have anything off this list I am in withdrawal for 5 days before the withdrawal symptoms stop. The compulsion to eat all of my addictive list lasts the full 5 days. Then I have no compulsion to eat anything, and as long as I avoid those foods I have no real hunger feeling much at all. It totally goes away.

    A second type of compulsive eating was shown on a Dr M Mosley documentary where they showed a trick of food manufacturers. If they make the amount of fat and sugar component of a food equal then their is no off switch when we eat them. E.g glazed donuts, cheese cake.

    Hope this helps you, and if I were you I’d get rid of the Bingeing Queen name and get something that doesn’t reinforce your challenge. Get something positive rather than a negative. Words are powerful things and seeing yourself continually as the queen of bingeing won’t be helpful to you. Find something aspirational that gives you a good self image when you write it, read it, or think about it.

    Best wishes,
    Merry

    Hi guys I’m new to this need to lose about 2 stone I binge a lot please help me. Need tips on exercise and food as I am a vegetarian. Thank u

    Merry me that’s fascinating and brilliant! Well done for persevering. I think if I can justify it in my head as some kind of intolerance I feel better about completely eliminating some of these things. I think it was jade on these boards that once suggested trialling only goods that I don’t binge on, and these tally with advice from Annette and Lolly, the low carb.

    All cereals and grains are a definite bit how interesting. I have people star at me aghast when they see I can overeat in porridge, yes porridge and want to keep going and going.

    Ria 88, Firstly I’ll say welcome. There is some great advice on this board, with some very thoughtful posters who can offer all their experiences and will help support you. Have you tried intermittent fasting Ria?

    Binge queen thank u for your response I have not tried anything of the sort before. Just looking for some startup advice please I can’t stop eating junk food it’s a constant struggle I really need to change this please help

    Congrats Merry for your endurance – so pleased for you!
    Welcome Ria, we understand what you go through – your questions are so broad I might suggest you take a stroll through the pages here to see what a battle we’ve had. Also you should def get the 5:2 book and read about intermittent fasting, also google Drs Jason Fung and Robt Lustig, just to see how foods affect us and indeed how food is deliberately processed in hopes of addicting us. I always found words like addiction and poison a bit strong, but to a binger it’s pretty much a thing.

    But we are winning, by educating ourselves, and for most of us it’s just as Merry explained. Find what foods set you off. Almost every woman I know can be triggered by sugar or white flour. Maybe other grains as well. I found my way by following Annette into the “whole foods” realm (kicking and screaming) and found that I could gain weight on those too but something was indeed happening. I was losing my craving for junk. So I moved on to eliminating grains and have found, very much like Merry, I can have a little and I’m fine. Which is awesome because I rarely want more than a little now at I’ve learned to love other whole foods again.

    If you’re serious, Ria, it is a process that can take some time. Two steps forward, one step back, etc. Queen i know how hard you’ve tried, and believe me I know how that time of month gets worse later, whew glad that’s over for me! But I am so much healthier and happier without sugar being a daily part of my diet. I did have to do exactly as Merry said, go thru a withdrawal process. Months of that. Now I find I can have almost anything in a “treat” category if I am careful not to hav too much. All junk food, sugar, and grains are in the treat category. I do NOT have daily treats. I know, what’s ****ing left?? Lots of great things: protein (eggs, fish, meats, etc.) veg, fruit, good fats, even a bit of wine, all yummy. It took me over a year to get to this point though. I feel that I went thru stages as I was ready for the next step. First gave up sugar, then some grains, then all grains, then grapes, then gradually felt in control enough to have a bit of those if I concentrate on mainly LCHF and fruit. Sorry for the super serious post, islanders, but school’s about to start, guess I’m getting in teacher mode๐Ÿค“Hugs all, gotta run.๐ŸŒด๐Ÿ”†๐ŸŒดjade

    I have realized that I now eat to live…rather than live to eat which is what I had been doing for many years. I eat very simply now, scrambled eggs and smoked salmon for lunch or avocado and salad. Dinner is often meat/fish and vegetables or salad. Now I try to eat fruit with my meal so that there is a gap of several hours without food, between meals.

    I eat bread(2 slices of wholemeal toasted) perhaps up to twice a week, rice perhaps once a week and pasta I haven’t had for a couple of weeks…and I don’t miss it. There are aisles in shops that I never go down. I am a sugar addict, fine if I don’t have it, but if I have a biscuit, piece of cake, ice cream…then I am like a heat-seeking missile looking for my next fix.

    Tango-Krav Maga is hand to hand combat. Lesson number 3 last night and I love it. I always wanted to learn self defense and I think that all women should do this. It is a full body workout with the warm up including core exercises that I am starting to learn to do. It is said that it takes 16 weeks to see an improvement in fitness, I think that it might take rather longer!

    Lolly- clearly we(the carb scoffers) are the unhinged ones. Don’t suppose the food industry would be pleased if we all gave up rice/pasta/bread.

    Merryme-really interesting to hear about your experience. I learn so much here on this forum.

    Queen, I am very stubborn and resisted having less carbs less often, but having dragged Jade kicking and screaming into the world of wholefoods, I thought that I really should try it and see how I felt, how I behaved and whether I thought that my mood was more stable. Give it a try for a week, just 1 week.

    Jade-great to hear that you have found what works for you and that you sound much recovered now, which is great.

    Tango, forgot to answer your question about the soggy caulicrust pizza. Doesn’t matter how you cook it really, but some recipes recommend putting the cooked, riced cauliflower into a dish/tea towel and squeezing out as much liquid as possible. I used a mesh strainer and pushed with a big spoon and that seemed to do the trick. Also, I used 2 eggs the first time, just 1 the second, with a bit more cheese to help bind it all together, and that made it better, too. Plus I cooked the darn thing about twice as long as called for, and flipped it over before topping – I like a crisp crust!

    That sounds like a ton of work but it wasn’t, I’m just not very concise today! xx
    ps Hi Annette, not kicking and screaming anymore I promiseโ™ฅ๏ธ

    Hi there!

    Such a lot to take it, and so many ideas flying around!

    Jade-gold dust, thanks for those tips! ๐Ÿ˜‰ I’ll try again at some point. Back brace sounds good to get out and about.

    Merryme-thanks for the information, it does make sense, and I know some food has that effect me as you describe, and it is out of my life, but I’m still trying to quit others! I have often wondered about the elimination diet but imagine it’s better with supervision? I noticed you added Buckwheat, which I thought was quite ‘safe’ as not a grain, in fact I’ve just used it for the first time yesterday, early days, but hope I won’t be craving it. I’m not good with rice, but can eat lentils/chickpeas. I also think that I have a more traditional intolerance alongside addiction as I get indigestion but can never identify the food.

    Ria, welcome this is an awesome forum and we’ve all embraced this WOL and made adjustments along the way. I gave up pasta/potato/bread etc after I was diagnosed with low thyroid. Bread is my worst trigger so it’s pretty much banned, potatoes and pasta I really never eat nor never miss, weird how certain foods really do it. I’m also a veggie, but eat fish, eggs and some cheese. Take your time, and read the forum threads there is a lot of info out there.

    Queen, I also can binge oats! If I was a horse I’d have a bag of them around my neck! seriously ALL cereals are banned from my house, granola, muesli and oats. I used to end up eating the mini-cereal packs I bought for my nephews! but still not out of the woods. I agree with Merryme, but also believe other forces can be at work. I’ve attached a link that deals with food sensitivities which may of interest, it’s related to Paleo but still useful:
    http://autoimmune-paleo.com/breaking-the-cycle-of-food-cravings-why-are-we-drawn-to-foods-that-harm-us/

    So I’m coming towards the end of the term, and hopefully a period of a bit of chilling out, I’ve still got work for 2 and a bit more weeks (counting the days) but then have a 2 week ‘staycation’ after that. I haven’t been able to do fasting properly due to PMT slash personal worries, but I’m not gaining weight, thank god! that would be the pits. I’m really going to keep an eye out for these intolerances make sure that the right things are banged on the head. I love nuts but they might not be that good for me! so will be mindful, I’ve had indigestion on and off for 5 days, and it may be some pistachios, nuts do tend to have mould content, e.g cashews, peanuts and pistachios ๐Ÿ™ I’ve said it before that life is too short so I don’t want to get to hung up on what I put in my mouth! there has to be a balance.
    Annette thanks for the Krav Maga sounds awesome, I would like to do a martial art, not sure which one, Taewondo always appealed. You sound like you’re in a good place, fabulous!

    Sending cyberhugs to all

    I am struggling to see any difference on either the scales or the tape measure around my waist despite my reduction in sugar as well as now having one meal a day without rice/pasta/potatoes and often both meals. One one level it is very disappointing that having made such big changes, there is little apparent reward.

    I eat a lot of fish with salad or vegetables, fruit/nuts/seeds. I no longer bake or have a cake, biscuit, ice cream in the house..because I am unable to have just one. The sugar turns me into a lunatic looking for my next fix, so I donโ€™t have the temptation.

    However, I have to remind myself that 90 minutes of Krav Maga is a full body workout and that I have just completed week 3 and that I am probably increasing my muscle mass-hopefully.It is said that after 16 weeks that there will be a big increase in physical fitness, which is also my aim. I am also sure that I have more obvious muscles in my abdomen, which I hope will also increase!

    In conclusion, I am just going to keep with 2 FD a week and continue with my much healthier diet and keep the faith that it is a much better way to live and that there will be some shrinkage to my waist over the coming months.

    Hi Tango

    I needed to do my elimination diet under supervision, and it took 14months because I continually had to fight through the 5day addiction thing and didn’t always make it so had to start the 5 days over. Only 1 thing was challenged at a time and if OK was added to the list of things Zi could eat. It took a lot oatience and perserverance. My intolerance list is loooong, and includes quite a few things other than grains .

    Last bowl of porridge was what finally sent me to the dietician, after an extreme reaction. Before breakfast I was organized, had my head on straight, big day to get through, focused. 1/2 hr after my oat porridge I couldn’t think straight, foggy brain, unfocused, disorganised thinking, lasted hours, difficult to get through the day.

    Elimination diet started with 1 week on 5 foods no-one reacts to : lamb, rice, skinned pear, and 2 others I can’t remember right now. Well no- one reacted to rice, on the record, till me. The reactions didn’t fully go away and in discussion with dietition, we dropped the rice for a further week, and reactions stopped 5 days in. D said I was 1st person they’d ever seen or heard of reacting to rice. I also had allergy tests and gastroscopy. Came back negative for ceoliac but positive allergy to oats and rye. The only grain I don’t react to in any way is corn.

    Allergies are triggered by the immune system
    Intolerances are gut related – in intestines
    Allergists and intolerance specialists don’t agree on things, so there is a bit of confusion and misunderstanding of intolerances.

    Intolerances have a threshhold level., and this can go up or down over the years, worse during times of stress. So, when I did the full elimination diet/testing my thresholds were low – I could eat only tiny amounts or none of some things before I reacted. Now my threshold are much higher as I live a much less stressed life, so for eg I react to sulphite preservative in dried fruit and within 1/2 hr my reaction was to fall asleep for a few hours, ditto for preservative in deli meats. Now I can have small amounts of these without falling asleep. My worst reaction during the elimination testing period was to fall asleep within 1/2 hr and I slept for 24 hrs!. Weird hey!

    Re buckwheat not being a grain – chia are seeds, but I react in that particular way to buckwheat and chia as well, so for me it’s not just grains. Gluten is one of my addictive reaction foods as well as causing other symptoms, but I’m not ceoliac. Had the biopsy, negative.

    I have various other foods I’m intolerant to with varying physical symptoms, including mood and cognitive symptoms, and I react to some of the natural chemicals in foods even in some fruits, vegetables, and other natural foods. Its b………. boring!

    Anyway….back to the things with addictive reactions. They are whatever they are for you. If you are really troubled by reactions then I recommend getting elimination testing done under supervision. There were quite a few surprises in my journey, things I didn’t even realise were reactions, and I definitely couldn’t have done it on my own.

    Hope this helps,
    Cheers,
    Merry

    Tango, what a fantastic link, thank you! And I thought Jason Fung was easy to understand – this was brilliant and applies to all regardless of paleo. And good for you for maintaining, sometimes our best efforts to lose result in just holding the line BUT it beats the hell out of packing it back on.

    Happily having a day off over here, though there are some student papers I have to read (summer projects). So unmotivated for the new school year!! Hoping it’s like Christmas, I’m always the one who isn’t going to get into the hoopla, then around Dec 15 I go insane wrapping, baking, decorating, and always have a lovely time of it. But before the spirit hits, I am just a lump. Actually, feeling that way about food isn’t such a bad thing. Lately I really haven’t had much appetite, probably because of the back thing and meds. Amazing how much time I ordinarily spend thinking about food though!๐Ÿค”๐Ÿ˜œ All right, off with me to read these fascinating papers๐Ÿ˜‘good luck to any fasters out there๐Ÿ’ช๐ŸŒด๐Ÿ”†โ™ฅ๏ธxxx

    Hi Annette,

    Are you counting calories on your FDs and nonFDs. Usually when the scales don’t go down it’s because the calories are more than TDEE on the 5 non fast days. Check out the calories in the fruit, nuts and seeds you’re eating. You may have to lower the quanitity of these.

    PS Also check the calories in what you’re drinking.

    Cheers,
    Merry

    I am quite conflicted by those that say that all calories are not equal and it is pointless to count them but I also feel that as I am ‘stuck’ and have been for a while, that there is nothing else to do. So back to the notebook to log and count for the next few weeks. I drink water or tea (without sugar). I suspect that nuts are my downfall.

    Annette, me too, and I’ve had to interpret that to mean just that 200 calories of, say, avocado is more satisfying than 200 calories of potato chips, and that I’ll eat less overall as a direct consequence of choosing the avocado.
    But if I’m told the “calories don’t matter” as long as I eat X and not Y, I will then rebel and eat such a truckload of X, fantasizing about Y, trying to make X taste like Y, that I guarantee I will gain weight, all the time miserable that I can’t have Y. It’s one reason that I can’t hack LCHF, even though many of my days look like LCHF. So yeah, when I’ve gained, it’s because I’ve eaten too much — and it’s time to find out what and why.

    Jade-such a shame that we are so complex!

    I wonder if keeping tabs on what I eat is just as important? Maybe there will come a time when I will eat and not keep a log. I certainly hope so. But for now, that is just what I am going to do, to see if I can make any other changes.

    Annette,

    Im in the camp that says all calories are not processed by the body in the same way, both physiologically and psychologically. Fats are processed different to protein which is different to simple carbs/sugar. 100 calories of avocado will have a different response to 100 calories of sugar. Don’t think its true? Do an experiment. For one week allocate 200 calories of your TDEE by eating an avocado (approx. 125g). Then repeat the experiment the next week by allocating 200 calories per day with a chocolate donut (about 50g). The rest of your daily TDEE can be composed of whatever it is currently. See how your mental state and your waistline cope. Im pretty sure I know what will happen but the experiment should produce results that will crystallise, in your own mind, the differences.

    I don’t think that all calories are processed in the same way either, but I am at a loss despite big changes to my diet, to make any changes to my weight or waistline. About 18 months ago, after seeing ‘Trust me I am a doctor’ I was shocked at how much caffeine was in tea and at that time I was drinking 7/8 mugs a day, so I decided overnight to cut that down to a daily total of 3, which I did. What I hadn’t thought about was that it was also going to mean reducing my sugar consumption by 35 tsp/week. I had a shocking headache for 2 weeks but thought it was caffeine withdrawal, but I think it was sugar instead.
    I was introduced to ‘that sugar book’ by Damon Gameau and as a result started to look more carefully at my diet for hidden sugar. I noticed that when I ate a pudding at work, I felt rubbish all afternoon, so had a week without any puddings and felt much better. So I reduced the sugar in my tea from a teaspoon to a half, and gave up completely before Christmas which was quite an achievement after 40 years!
    I ditched jar tomato sauces and changed to wholemeal pasta and to brown rice, made sure that anything ‘diet’ or ‘low fat’ didn’t cross the threshold and stopped buying fruit yoghurts or chocolate mousse-much loved by my boys. I make my own yoghurt from full fat milk.
    For the past month, lunch has been fish or avocado with salad. Evening meals have been meat/fish with vegetables or salad. I feel better without rice/bread/pasta every day but did expect to see some changes by now.
    I think that my shape is better but I still have a way to go to get to a waist that is half the height and I am only short. I am at a loss to know what changes I can make to achieve that and I suspect that nuts are my down fall-I love them.
    So, in quiet desperation, I am going to continue to avoid the sugar and eat wholefoods, but restrict the quantity and see what happens. I love avocados and cannot bear doughnuts, but miss sticky toffee pudding has no doubts that the problem lies in the white stuff.

    Hi there,

    Just got the lowdown on nuts, I didn’t include the vits/minerals nor the carbs, as they are mainly ‘lowish’ carb.

    25 grms of Almonds, 160 cals, 6 grms protein, 14 grms fat (about 23 nuts)
    25 grms of Pistachios, 158 cals, 6 grms protein, 13 grms fat (49 shelled nuts)
    25 grms of Pecans, 196 cals, 3 grms protein, 20 grms fat (20 halves)
    25 grms of Cashews, 157 cals, 5 grms of protein, 13 grms of fat (16 to 18 nuts)
    25 grms of Walnuts, 185 cals, 4 grms protein, 18 grms of fat (high in Omega 3) (14 halves)

    I find that it is really easy to overeat nuts, I tend to go for Pistachios cos there are more! and once you’ve shelled them you can’t be bothered to shell more. You can freeze them, and just take out your daily portion? but I’ also wondering if I can have a trial with no nuts, they are my main protein as I don’t eat meat but do eat fish.

    Yes I’m confused about the calorie issue which is also linked to what type of food. I think what happens is the body reacts differently to calories, so if we have something of 100 cals, laden with sugar, there is likely to be a insulin spike, which floods the body, and the body might react by having to store this energy, glycogen in fat cells, correct me if I’m wrong. On the other hand, if it’s 100 cals of protein with a high fibre content, the process is slower and likely to be used for energy/repair etc..

    This way of life is very slow, and the other day I read a thread that talked of the 4 P’s planning, preparing, preservation, and patience, think it’s so true..we’ve all been there! Also read ‘Your goal must outweigh your temptation’ that has rang very true to me, as sometimes I’ve lost sight of my goal, and it doesn’t seem very tangible. I’m going to sit down and work out some more concrete goals. I don’t work well, with clothes as a goal, that comes much later..

    Happy fasting to all

    T x

    I love almonds, brazils and walnuts and could easily scoff several handfuls a day. My plan is to weigh them out as a daily amount and see how that goes. I was thinking about going nut free for a week as well, but that seems a bit miserable when they are good for me, I love them and I have made so many positive changes to my diet(stopped buying 6 pack of ice creams en robed in chocolate with chopped almonds-Heaven) they never last more than a few days.

    Robert Lustig is of the opinion that more wholefoods which take longer to digest and don’t cause the rapid increase in blood sugar and then increase of insulin which has to store the excess sugar as fat somewhere(visceral fat the most dangerous). It gets complicated as we have been told for so long that fat is the food to avoid rather than the white stuff. What is a healthy diet? I think that it is one with nuts, olive oil, meat, fish, fruit, vegetables, cheese and full fat yoghurt. I think that fasting is very important too especially after hearing what Jason Fung has to say about it on You Tube.

    I will keep you posted how it goes. Out for lunch today at a pub. Ho hum.

    hope you don’t mind me joining in
    I haven’t posted on this thread for some time now, but still follow it

    I am interested in what you are saying about the low carb eating, as I had to stop the fasting because it was causing dire reflux problems, so I now do LCHF

    it seems to suit me better
    but I have to admit there are people on the BSD forum who are losing insane amounts, and I mean like 3 stone in 8 weeks, a stone in 2 weeks etc
    it is NOT like that for me but I am losing it

    I have found I need to keep my carbs VERY low
    around 20-30g/day which means I have had to cut back even on the veg I was eating(temporarily)
    it is quite surprising how much carb is in the fruit and veg we eat

    I also only currently eat berries – so all exotic fruits and even apples/pears/bananas are out

    I don’t feel hungry, but I also don’t seem to have the ‘verve’ that others seem to get from this way of eating (would be nice!!)

    anyway, just thought I would say this

    good wishes to you all xx

    Goodness KT, how interesting.

    I went out for lunch with my friend yesterday which meant a walk of an hour each way, which was lovely. I had fish and chips with a small glass of cider( I rarely drink any alcohol) as we sat in the sunshine. I just had fruit in the evening with a 25g serving each of almonds and walnuts, which just confirms how liberal I have been!

    I am trying to change what my overweight son chooses to eat. He works in a restaurant and has a limited choice when he is working a full shift, but the difficulty for him is that when he works a ‘split’ and is left to his own devices for a meal in the middle of the day. He is losing weight with what we are eating at home, but now I think that I need to talk to him about making ‘better’ choices when he is out and about. He has Aspergers and for him, that means that he is quite rigid about what food he will eat but on the plus side he has been willing to try having meat and veg or salad when he is at home. We menu plan together and he has chosen chilli with wraps for tonight, so later I will be talking to him about whether he wants 2 wraps and no rice, or 1 wrap with a small amount of rice. He finds change difficult but I have been careful to suggest small changes with food that he likes, as this needs to be something that he can maintain on his own.

    Onwards and downwards fast friends.

    Hi all,

    I was trying LC, well, a lot more low carb than usual, but today felt tired, they were doing chocolate ice creams (360 kcal each in the supermarket), and for some reason I brought them. When I got home, guess what, despite having breakfast and lunch, nom nom. Gone. You know that reluctance to let go of carbs Annette?! I did notice my mood picked up a bit afterwards though.

    Annette, it sounds like you are trying really hard with your son which is wonderful.

    Now I go away with all my family for the week. It will be stressful, lots of children who are not my blood relatives and some only eat sugary cereals, white bread, pizza and cake!! So stress and carbs… I really struggle with early mornings too as my little one gets up at 06.00 now and no-one else part from the children wake up at this time and bizarrely it’s a peak binge time for me between 06.00- 12.00! Because others are rising so I’m trying to think of a plan for this week. Just venting but feel resentful that others can’t be a bit more sympathetic to my lack of willpower… and surrounding me with white carbs and biscuits! Ultimately it’s up to me to control my behaviour though. Today with the chocolate ice creams reminded me, it takes a few whoops moments and feeling tired and I have gobbled everything up.

    Keep trying thank you for sharing! So you are losing weight? were you a binger previously? are you able to resist carbs i.e doughnuts when faced with them now, or do you just keep them out of sight?

    I think probably, for some, a very low amount of carbs rather than none at all is probably better for them, however, for those of us with no willpower it’s very tough to moderate.

    Still concerned that my mood has really perked up after all that sugar. I was feeling very grumpy prior to it.

    have a lovely weekend and sorry about the random vent!

    Hi Queen,
    Sugar will pick up your mood and then it will fall, making you seek out more. It really is a vicious cycle BUT I found that just taking it day by day was how I coped with the change. I was a bit like an alcoholic, repeating the mantra ‘one day at a time’. I also noticed that as the days went by that my mood stabilized and I was free of feeling grumpy, having something sweet which cheered me for a while, before my mood dropped with the sugar crash. I know that might seem a bit bonkers to you, but give it a go for a few weeks and I am sure that you will feel much much better and more able to cope with the family stress.

    Can I suggest that you simply try and avoid the white bread, rice, pasta etc to say nothing of the stuff that has the white stuff inside while you are away with the hordes. Planning is the key, so if you can think of some meals that you would enjoy that are going to be available.

    Lunch for me today was half a pack(100g) of smoked salmon and x2 scrambled eggs, followed by a banana, apple and 25g almonds. This evening my son is having chilli that I will make for him(portion for 4. Three of which will then be frozen for another time). I will either have a salmon fillet sprinkled with parmesan and baked for 20 minutes or an avocado with salad and homemade dressing.

    The bottom line is that you will have to make the choices about what you are going to eat. I appreciate that you will have more time on your hands with your little one getting up at 6, but you do need a plan. Perhaps a cup of something hot when you get up and then waiting until 7 before you prepare yourself something to eat. Try having bacon and eggs, without the bread. For lunch/evening meal aim to eat fish or meat with salad or vegetables and I am sure that you will feel better than the carb high and lows fueled by the white stuff.

    I hope that you have a lovely time and the experience is much better than you anticipate. It may well be tiring, but sugar isn’t going to help, quite the opposite even if you can’t see that now. A few weeks down the line though..and you will. I never thought that sugar had much impact on my mood, but now I know that it does and pasta makes me sleepy.

    hi bingeingqueen

    oh yes indeed I know all about bingeing as I have binge eating disorder

    so all this ‘good’ eating behaviour is a battle almost every day
    and horrible when something has triggered a binge
    I am afraid I often resort to alternative ‘self destructive’ methods just so that I can avoid the food but it doesn’t always work

    a few things I now know, though
    – no matter how desperate I feel for that first mouthful of a binge food – usually cake/biscuit/chocolate – the SECOND mouthful is even harder to resist
    and once I start it is very hard to stop as I can get quite unaware of how much is going in, and my head plays all sorts of ‘its ok you need it’ tricks
    – I can binge on dark chocolate (though admittedly not so fast and not so much) but it has unpleasant side effects like keeping me awake all night
    – I need to keep binge foods out of the house most of the time

    regarding low carb, I have to admit I don’t feel any energy boost at all, indeed often quite the opposite
    I wonder how I walked so far when I was 2.5 stone heavier (guess it was sugar power)

    but I am eating healthier so hopefully that is generally good (although my stupid cholesterol has also gone up since losing weight duh!!)

    I have really noticed what an energy boost sugar is for me, as the other week I had lots of dark choc and had TONNES of energy, until I crashed the other side and could hardly stay awake
    and even weds, I wondered why I wasn’t so tired in the evening and then remembered the 1.5 gf choc chip cookies I had had earlier

    I think my body wants to run on simple carbs and is very reluctant to burn fat

    but yes I am losing weight
    last week it was 4.5 pounds, but that is a freak amount, usually its around a pound or so a week

    also I still have a good 3 stone to lose to be a healthy weight for my height

    Hey islanders – indeed, the sugar high is so deceptive. It makes us feel good bc we are so used to it. Queen it took me MONTHS to break the habit, and I’m not just kidding about the kicking and screaming. But as for true LCHF I just don’t care to do it. KT I feel flatter than a stagnant pond when I try it. I guess they say you get used to it but I’ve done several weeks and I just almost would’ve killed someone for an apple. And ended up eating way too much, hating most of it because it wasn’t what I wanted. Ah, different strokes….

    However, NOW almost every day still looks LCHF, at least until dinner. Queen, I really think that might be the secret for you. Just hold off eating the carbs as long as you can, preferably until dinner. And even then, don’t eat them alone (and yes, I was the champion doughnut-in-car on empty stomach girl). Just don’t. When you eat carbs, make sure you’re also eating some good protein and fat. And HA HA NO THAT IS NOT MILK CHOCOLATE, though I tried to convince myself of that before.

    It’s not exactly a miracle but feels like one – when I have meat/fish and veg, I may still want dessert but I’m not insane for it. And if I have it, I can stop. I am not insane, is the point. The protein and fats are like a blood sugar shield.๐Ÿ›ก๐Ÿ›ก

    I know how desperate it can make you feel. You’ll be surrounded by people noshing on foods you love. I promise it will help if you avoid the carbs at least at 6 a.m.! Tell yourself you can have them later, with dinner, just don’t waken the carb monster during the day. We all know what he can do, he can make you feel as though your day is shot, so why not throw caution to the wind.

    If there is any one thing I know not to do now, it is have carbs at breakfast. Even if I have them at lunch, I make sure that they are not the focus of the meal. Maybe a piece of bread to go with the protein/veg. Try this, see if it helps. It’s hard to do all the kids and meals, baby steps will help. We’re here for you in the rehab cave!!โ™ฅ๏ธ๐ŸŒดโ™ฅ๏ธxx

    Hi there!

    Queen, I’ve been there with the early starts, I used to be a nanny (years ago) and being up early with kids often meant for me mindless eating out of tiredness ๐Ÿ™ and then suddenly it’s lunchtime and you just eat for the sake of it. Do you like coffee? having a little double cream with coffee starves of the hunger pangs and is delicious. I use this to get me through to the evening meal, that and loads of water. You could also use coconut oil and blitz it in a blender. The calorie count is not that high. Since this is a week only could you ‘let yourself off the hook’ but be mindful, then when you return have a plan of action.

    Hi KT, thanks for sharing, that’s an amazing loss. Sugar doesn’t make me feel energetic, but it makes me happy! I’m a huge emotional eater, and in the past could make a pack of biscuits disappear like Woody Woodpecker. I’ve had to admit it’s an addiction and there are foods which are just too ‘dangerous’ to have around. Since LC I’m in more control.

    Jade you’re so right about ‘different strokes’ we all react differently to different foods, but our shared vision is what keeps us going! trying to be ‘normal’ around food and getting healthy

    Annette, wow I totally admire your commitment to this WOL, it’s an inspiration to read. I’m also going lower on the nuts, and might remove them temporarily ๐Ÿ™ not for too long as they have some amazing vits/minerals but think for me they pack on the weight.

    I’m now day 36, in the 100 non-booze challenge! amazing, now not even a blink of the eye. It was hard for a couple of days, and I overdid the soda and lime, but am now pleased as feel good, not so much physically as mentally. Someone told me my hair looked good the other day, and that hasn’t happened for a long time! I was also given some high potency Vit D tablets which I have to take for 10 weeks! my mood does feel better.

    Merryme mentioned an elimination diet, but that would be beyond my budget, so am looking at removing some suspect foods temporarily from my diet, to see if I can shift some pounds. I haven’t lost any weight for ages, so am overeating somewhere! I’m also thinking of joining a local group called Food Addicts, it does kind of scare me as not sure if I’m in the category but I definitely have a problem, it could be good support.

    I’m on the last few days of a ‘marking marathon’ but will be slipping out today as the local Samba band are playing very near where I live, result!
    Hugs and positive vibes to all
    T
    P.S Jade thanks for the update on the Cauli pizza! great tips! ๐Ÿ™‚

    Eerily quiet on the island ๐Ÿค” Tango, how great that you’re doing so well with the no-booze challenge. My hubs is one of those types who can either not drink at all or baby ust give him the 6-pack and let’s make it a party! So he’s been taking it easy lately on the booze (and the junk food) and has lost a good 10 lbs of spare tire.๐Ÿ’ช

    Nibbling snacks and sugary things has always been my problem, but of late my appetite has suffered. It’s been weird y’all, I mean if this is normal it’s kind of boring. I enjoy a meal out but have had little interest in cooking or eating at home. Granted, there is little to excite anyone around here, but plenty to chow down on believe me. The meds and the back pain, neither that severe, have been just enough to shift my focus, maybe? And also simply relaxing and being at peace with the scale where it was. But (drumroll) for the last week, I hit and have stayed at my original goal point, the one I haven’t seen since I was a teenager. Seems rather cosmic to say once I gave up trying to reach it, the scale gave up too? Anyway, I’m feeling better each day, though not great, and given the side effects of the meds, this is a much better side effect! To celebrate, I actually had breakfast, an egg on toast.

    So maybe I’ll spend a bit of time in the hammock outside the rehab cave๐Ÿ”† Once my appetite is back it won’t be so easy, I know. But I am simply uninterested in food for food’s sake at the moment. I do get hungry, and those first few bites are good, but there is no insanity. Holy catz I really don’t know how it happened, other than landing in the ER with back pain. I will try desperately to figure out and share, if there’s any secret other than simply not feeling well. Hugs to you all, islanders, whatever your goals and struggles I hope you have a great day๐Ÿ’Ÿ๐ŸŒด๐Ÿ”†xxxx

    Maybe Jade, you are joining me on the ‘eat to live rather than live to eat’ attitude. I have been aware that although I enjoy eating food that is simple and nutritious, it doesn’t give me that sugar high. I am satisfied by eating meals of fish or meat with salad or vegetables and then having some fruit to finish. I am trying to have a gap between meals of several hours too.

    I am a nut addict. So I have decided to stop the nut/seed meusli mixture for breakfast for a while and see what that effect that might have on any waist shrinkage. I am going to have bacon and eggs for breakfast instead. I am struggling to fit in a FD, so missed breakfast and then was out with friends for cake in the afternoon.

    It is certainly helping my son to lose weight by having several meals a week that have salad or vegetables without rice/pasta/potatoes/bread.He is shrinking despite working in a restaurant and having some meals there.

    Well done Tango on the no booze challenge. I am just stubborn, but recognize that I am a nut addict and so will try a while without and then see if there is any difference to the waist measurement.

    I am away for the weekend to stay with a friend. No idea what food will be available, so will just go with the flow and see where I am next week…until I go away for another few days.But as we all know, this is a marathon and not a sprint.

    Hi,

    Jade, I’m sorry to hear about your back. I know actually being ill has sometimes been a relief as its reduced my appetite.
    I think if you have been in pain enjoyment is hard to achieve, from any other source.

    Ah well I tried lchf, first day wonderful I swear I looked instantly slimmer, second day ok but ate a lot of goats cheese. Next day I went to the gym and it felt like I was walking through syrup, or no energy, however, all clothes felt looser. Next day, bad night’s sleep. Got up and had a coffee with skimmed milk and then goats cheese, then more goats cheese, ok so a block of goats cheese, then some Brie, then some dark dark choc (90 percent). Then peanut butter… Half a tub, I started and thought this is actually a nightmare I just want more. Whole day was a massive binge. So the low carb didn’t stop the binge and then in the end I decided I might have had around 7000 kcal, I then went into eating “whatever in the house” and there were cakes cream etc. It isn’t the most ideal setting being around kids two that are underweight (not mine) so need to keep feeding and food everywhere but it’s just me. I’m really grumpy And like a woman possessed searching for more.

    I am at a loss with myself!

    So with low carb, first two days decided I had found a miracle then realised I actually just binge on high fat food given the opportunity. Problem with high fat foods is I have (not as much as carb) but that same “I want more” feeling.

    So today I thought I would start out well but peanut butter is fatal. The urge to keep eating it is actually horrid! I looked at the kcal label it’s about 1500 kcal for a small tub and I had had half a tub in one go and just keep thinking about it!

    hi bingeingqueen

    I have to admit some of the high fat foods can also trigger bingeing in me
    specifically cheese – cheddar mmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

    I can’t binge on meat, or veg, so I stick to them mostly but I think I may have to put a padlock on the cheddar pretty soon
    and peanut butter possibly but not yet

    I find sugars/carbs the most addictive to me

    also I have found – having gone ridiculously low in carbs the last 2 weeks, that my body cannot deal with all that fat (funny how it manages to when mixed with sugar!!)
    so I have brought the fat down some and upped the veg carbs again

    I have to admit that unlike most people it seems, I have yet to experience any energy boost from this woe
    but it does help me lose weight
    and that is key at the moment

    some people seem to go way high on fats but for some of us I don’t think that will ever work – as I have discovered not only with the eating but also the constant upset stomach!!

    however I am having peanut butter on my coconut flatbreads for lunch ๐Ÿ™‚

    Peanut butter!!! Argh never again, or goats cheese… Let’s just say a tub in a day went…. Before 10am! It’s odd t brain says it will ruin my day, I’ll feel sick but I have some foods and am a greedy piggy it is just as hard to moderate my consumption as it is to say no. I don’t do small quantities! I read about an American solider who could only control his weight by having one meal a day- a disciplined soldier! Although his colleagues thought he was well disciplined for eating only one meal, he stated that it was in fact became he lacked discipline that he only had one, at the end of the day…

    Ah, but just shows there is a solution for everyone, Queen! One meal a day = intermittent fasting benefits, too. Brilliant. I did that once, having maybe a V8 to tide me over until dinner (REALLY hard to binge on that).

    Try as I might, though, I can’t do LCHF. It’s not that I’m left hungry, it’s more than I want some carbs and can’t have them, so I overeat protein-fats trying to find satisfaction. Then I just feel bleah. But I agree, it’s an individual journey to find what works for each person.

    Omg KT you hit the nail – I can’t deal with all that fat unless there’s a bushel of sugar thrown in! ๐ŸฝCan’t really deal well with the sugar high either, at least its aftermath. But the high is addictive.

    So I’ve been thinking about what has changed in me lately. Annette, I think you’re right, and maybe it’s the cumulative effect of soldiering on with whole foods. Also eliminating grains until they lost their hold on me. I now have grains, but sparingly, and find that’s all I want anyway. They just don’t have the same luster.

    It could be that my apathy toward food is caused by the meds I was taking, but I really didn’t take them that long. I think a light just finally went out, for being sapped of power over the course of time. I get hungry and love those first bites, but after that it’s not love, it’s just food. Holy cow, I even leave food on my plate!! It is so ****ing weird. I do wonder if the body/brain, after a period of time, just acquiesces to the new regimen? Time will tell. Hugs to all you lovely islanders, come join me in the hammock – it’s lovely out today, we’ll have some nice iced tea, no sugar of course๐Ÿ”†โ™ฅ๏ธ๐ŸŒดjadexx

    Hi jade,

    Sorry if I’m making you repeat yourself but what grains are you avoiding? Are you still skipping brekkie ?

    What carbs are you eating?

    Your responses to lchf sounds like mine!

    I am surprised by just how little food that I need. I have been trying bacon and eggs with toast for breakfast and that is easily keeping me full until lunchtime. Lunch might be some smoked salmon and salad and then I might have a 3 egg omelette for dinner with some mushrooms and feel full. I am having rice or pasta perhaps once a week.

    I have been out with friends and there has been cake, which has been lovely but I think the ‘hold’ that the sweet stuff once had on me, the want to eat more and more..has waned. I often find that my memory of these things is at odds with the reality which has never been as good.

    I have completed a FD today and it was fine until I had lunch…and then I just wanted to eat. I have had a nut free few days and now I wonder if it was the nuts that have made me a bit of a lunatic this afternoon.

    I am going away for a few days and will be travelling at lunchtime both ways. The thought of what I might have to eat on the train has occupied my thoughts as I have weighed up the merits of treating myself to all those things that I usually avoid. I suspect that I will treat myself and then see how I feel afterwards.

    I am eating eggs, cheese, full fat yoghurt,butter, salmon, avocados, hummus and nuts along with meat, vegetables and fruit. I still have rice/pasta/potatoes but not every day and find that I feel better with less of them in my life.I will always love chocolate and cake, but I feel better with less in my life too.

    The interesting thing is that I don’t seem to be losing weight or inches. I suspect that the nut addiction is my down fall. Any thoughts?

    Interesting about the nut addiction — I had mentioned that once on this forum too. I definitely think it’s a factor for me…..not really an addiction but if I have nuts around, I overeat them, for sure, and though they are healthy, they are very high in calories. And I could quite mindlessly eat a ton of them!

    I can’t remember the last time I posted here. I have had my hip replacement surgery and am in week 8 of recovery. It has gone amazingly well. It is such a treat to be able to walk without that horrible arthritic pain. Because of that pain, I spent at least a year hardly moving at all. Biking hurt. Swimming hurt. I really just sat and watched tv and ate. Needless to say, 20 pounds at least have been packed on. I think I wrote all this once but I’ll refresh!

    I have always struggled with binge eating. Ever since I was a child I can remember sneaking food. I just had that mind set. As did my mother. Smoking in my younger years kept me from overeating and at a reasonable weight. Then when I quit smoking, the pounds came on and the binging returned.

    When I retired, I found a sport I just loved. Pickleball. I played it almost every day. My binging pretty much subsided. PLus, I stopped eating all grains and pretty much all sugar. That made a huge difference because, for me, much of the binging is an addition to grains and sugar. I was able to get off both, to have fun with pickleball, and to lose weight and not even think about overeating.

    then the arthritis pain in my hip started and I was unable to play pickleball or do any exercise. Grains and sugar started to creep in — though much of my binging is also on healthy food. but definitely eating when I’m not hungry and eating until I feel stuffed.

    I’m just starting to be able to get back out walking anyway. 4 more weeks of real hip precautions and I should be able to do other things like biking, swimming (playing in the pool really), line dancing. It will be probably a good year before I”ll be able to get back to pickleball, if I can.

    So I’m going to try to get back to my non-binging mode. So much for me is avoiding grains and sugar and I’ve been doing pretty well with that the last week or so. I know that I just eat too much though.

    A few years ago, I bought a book by Paul McKenna (I think he is British, isn’t he?) called Hypnotic Gastric Band. I think I tried it for a while and it did work for a bit. I’m going to try it again. One thing that he also recommends is The Havening Technique which is used to relax. It’s a series of tapping and eye movements and arm movements that are to decrease stress. I’ve done it a couple times today and it is very relaxing…..I’m going to try to do it whenever I have that feeling of binging.

    Anyway, I had been posting lots on a wonderful hip replacement forum. Now I’m feeling less of a need for that so will try posting here again. Nice to see everyone. Leslie

    Update-the scales have moved a little and lbs are now starting with a number that I haven’t seen for a while, so very pleased. I did struggle last night with the desire to go to the shops and return with chocolate and crisps. I even considered putting on my shoes and making the 10 minute trip(which I haven’t thought about in a very long time) so the only thing to do was to go to bed!

    I love nuts, but I can eat loads on a day. I think that they are going to have to be restricted to a NFD and a weighed out amount, well, that’s the plan!

    Hi Leslie, my friend went to see Paul McKenna some years ago and swears by the ‘eat until you are full and then put your fork down’ approach. She is shrinking by avoiding bread/rice/potatoes and pasta along with fasting until lunch for a couple of days. The real impact has been ditching the rubbish, of course, but I hope that she can continue with this way of life.

    I have just had to look at what Pickleball is, it looks like fun.I hope that your recovery goes well and that you are ‘back in the game’ avoiding sugar and grains. I certainly think that it has an impact on me,and although my clothes tell me that I am shrinking on the top half, I really really want some shrinkage on the tummy!

    Dear all,

    Hope everyone is well.

    FC welcome back! it’s lovely to hear from you, so glad that you are now in recovery with your hip surgery, it sounds quite a challenge! but equally am sending you positive cyber-hugs, hope you can get moving soon, the line-dancing would be great.

    Totally agree with the nuts, Annette think that’s a good plan, I find they are too addictive. I know it’s mainly sugar and grains that are the main culprits but because of the ‘handy’ size of nuts they are easy to nibble on, healthy yes, but wholefoods can pack on the weight.

    Had a bad week ๐Ÿ™ ‘put on’ 7 Ibs! yes you heard right, this was on Mon, I weighed myself Tues, thinking it must be a glitch, still 7!…was pretty depressed as have had no booze for about 40 days, surely not? You’ll be glad to know I have lost it now, but it was a scare. I think it was water retention as had ‘boobs the size of watermelons’ sorry for being so graphic, but a nasty side effect of perimeno.

    Queen I cannot have peanut butter in the house, impossible, it’s another one of the banned foods. Your story about the guy eating the one meal, struck a chord with me as I was thinking it wouldn’t be a bad thing, at least if the calories were a bit higher like the BSD, which is 800 cals for 8 days. Last week I think I mentioned going to the Food Addicts group. I went to my first one today, obvs can’t divulge any info, but feel it will be a great support, and rid me of some of the loneliness I feel around food. I’m not sure of the ‘holiness’ of some of the 12 steps, (you have to avoid all sugar and flour) but hope there is away of working around this. It’s comforting to know there are other people, of all sizes, all ages struggling with food.I will keep you posted on my progress

    Jade and Annette amazing!!, well done!! that you’ve both become less bothered about food, ๐Ÿ™‚ Sending you huge hi 5’s and wishing you more shrinkage Annette, you are both an inspiration to us all ๐Ÿ™‚

    Oh one more piece of good news. FINALLY have been to physio! I won’t be running for about 2 mths, but she said I can still Salsa!! whey hey! (I would’ve anyway tbh but nice to have the seal of approval) I will be going every week for about 10 weeks, gold dust!

    T xx

    hi everyone, i went through this thread and i’m astounded how much of this describes me ๐Ÿ™‚ easily going over 4000 kcal in one day without even noticing? going full animal mode for hours, devouring everything in range of sight? never feeling full untill it physically hurts or makes me feel really sick? not being able to keep any kind of food stored, because if i have a box/jar/containter of something i will inevitably eat it all once it’s opened? and the peanut butter monster, haha ๐Ÿ˜€ i made several attempts of keeping an open jar of it, dramatic failure each time (read: would eat it all within an hour or two).
    #SAME. a few years/months ago i didn’t really believe that anyone else experiences this and i’m just disgusting. recently i discovered it’s all human.

    i’m doing alternate day fasting. i though i could share with you my hacks for controlling bingeing that usually work for me. some of these might repeat what’s in this thread. i really read it but it’s 58 pages, might lost focus somewhere on the way and forgot that somethin’s already been mentioned. sorry in advance.
    – not starting the day with carbs, ideally leaving them for the last meal of the day (you spoke about it a lot). i couldn’t really force myself to do this for the last 6 months, especially after the dietician told me to get most/all of my carbs until 2pm. BUT. i get carbs, even healthy ones like brown rice or porridge or whatever = after 5 minutes i go to the fridge again. and then again. the logic that finally convinced my brain to stick to lc throughout the day was ‘carbs trigger bingeing’. telling myself that protein is healthier/better/makes you shed weight quicker never really worked.
    – not preparing food for the feeding day. the more i prepare in advance, the more i will eat, because i have it and because it can’t let it go bad, obviously.
    – preparing small portions. if i’m going to go for second helping anyway, no matter how much i’ve just had, then it can be a small portion as well. somehow it works.
    – in general try to prepare low volume meals. i’ve been always told to make use of the fact that i can stuff my stomach with salad (of course excluding some veggies high in calories) until it hurts if it’s going to keep me from bingeing on something unhealthy. although when i restarted ADF being now more mature and thoughful, i noticed that yes, it might do the job SOMETIMES, but the main effect on me is that the stomach never gets satisfied with small amounts! now i aim to size down my meals as it feels the right things to do.
    – going under 100 kcal on fasting days (which is every other day for me), having something very small just before sleep (like a cup of warm water with 5-10g of flaxseed powder -> fiber, protein, fat). i despise going to sleep hungry.
    – i bought a semi-professional scale/body composition analyser. i didn’t have a scale at home before. it’s has a HUGE impact on my discipline. i step on it everyday, because if i honestly stick to the diet there is no need to be scared to do this. if sometimes i feel reluctant… aha! plus, daily differences in body composition may be good hints at effects of certain foods on your body.

    probably i didn’t discover anything new here but maybe at least someone will feel encouraged to keep on going ๐Ÿ™‚
    cheers!

    Hi there,

    Welcome verdescuro (love the name) you’ll find great support and wisdom on this thread, and some great humour!

    I’ve not had a great weekend, migraine from yest to today ๐Ÿ™ gradually fading no pills would tame it. Am also quite undecided about the FA group. I wonder if anyone has done something like that before? There’s a part of it that really doesn’t appeal, and I think I can “do it alone” but maybe I can’t. Also, I think it it’s common to accept that when you go to groups as such to have misconceptions about what overeaters/bingers are like, and to feel that you don’t have such a big problem. I came away from the meeting humbled by the stories but not really knowing if my issues surrounding food (mainly body image and emotional eating) could be cured in this way. You have to abstain for 90 days (no sugar, no flour, no coffee, no booze (that’s ok ๐Ÿ˜‰ a lot of commitment, a sponsor you ring everyday. I still need to decide it is what I really want, I’m sure my resistance is completely normal.

    Hope the fasting is going well.

    T

    Verdescuro thank you for sharing! Wow what a list and you sound very self aware. I’m also really happy that you are finding something that works for you, do you still see a dietician? You have read a lot of posts!! I am so with you and think all your experiences are applicable to ne (however hard I try, however healthy it feels at the time, carbs seems to send me into sleepy I want more mode). Have you not had any binges on non fasting days? Do you feel really miserable on fasting days? I love also your not preparing food for a fast day, even if I prepare a light salad, I et quite obsessed… personally I also find preparing food whether it be healthy of unhealthy for other members of the family, a bit of a nightmare. I am like you I can binge on veggies too, and although I felt a bit guilty about it at the time, I polished a whole box of frozen berries after work, and yes it was greed, but it was stress eating and when I think what I had today after that brownie, a box of frozen berries seems like water in kcal terms. How do you find following ADF when (presuming you aren’t always alone) living with others?/ working with others? How do you find working on a fast day? my job has “responsible” elements to it and I fear the brain fog, although, after lunch I have such brain fog anyway…

    What is it about meetings and cake, and why is it the really slim people bring them in?!

    I had been following this loosely, i.e diet mainly of fish and vegetables (with some sauce of whatever – even if that contains sugar, but will only have the sauce in the evening). It had been working well, but today after three milky coffees I still felt tired and someone brought almond fudge cakes to a meeting, I thought I would be polite and had one… then it was like the brakes were off, I felt really tired and just wanted to eat all day. Not overeating is hard! I have to say, i love eating and am a bit miserable when I don’t have limitless supplies of food. I need to find something else to cheer me up or to boost energy when tired.

    Next few weeks I don’t have to make anyone else breakfast and I am going to try cutting down…yes you heard right, on my coffee and stopping breakfast. Daytime tiredness is such a struggle and going to see if it helps. I did notice I had fish and veggies for tea last night and I had no cravings afterwards…..

    T thanks also for sharing your experiences with Overeaters, I was tempted to go but couldn’t find one at a convenient time/location. Interesting (from my own perspective) they say to avoid coffee, why is that? is it because they says it’s addictive? (I’m definitely addicted to coffee but think my appetite would be through the roof without it!). What is your current approach to it all Tango?

    I just sometimes wish I could talk myself out of the moody lizard brain that just wants to eat. Joking aside, when I have been ill, like once said before, my appetite went and it was utter relief….

    Tango, I was also thinking 800 kcal in a one meal a day type of fasting day… peanut butter is probably the most addictive thing I have ever had, seriously, to me it tastes sweet, I can’t believe other people can moderate their intake of it, but wow. it tasted very good in the moment, now I have to work out a way to get rid of the extra pound I gained and get a hand on the bingeing!

    Welldone T for going to a group, you have to keep searching for something that suits you. You’re uniqueness may mean there may just be elements you can take from the group? Keep us posted on your progress. x

    Bingeingqueen – thank you a lot, i read your posts and so many times i thought wow, same ๐Ÿ˜€ i guess we have the same beinging gene ๐Ÿ™‚
    i totally did overeat on feeding days. 4000 kcal easily. now i stick to 1500-1600 kcal on eating days and 50 kcal on fasting days. this is very strict, i know, but it’s only temporary – until the end of september and i’m counting in a few days when surely i will eat more, eg. pms.

    i stopped seeing the dietician in february 2016 after a full year of treatment (ending up being 63kg/162cm). he decided that losing any more weight isn’t recommended for me because of my specific body composition and he presumed i won’t be able to sustain lesser weight. i still aim to slim down to some 57-58kg and get rid of all the fat storage from my legs which are out of proportion now. anyway, i would advice everyone to try dieting with a professional. i learned sooo much about my body.

    i work quite a lot and quite intensely. it’s half manual and half conceptual kind of job. no matter if it’s eating or fasting day i just keep doing what i have to do, no choice. i don’t have time to notice and ponder upon the ‘fog’. i think it’s a side effect of my general attitude – accepting that circumstances are rarely in our favour and we still have to keep on going. in Poland we say that you shouldn’t be scared to get wet when it rains, you’re not made of sugar ๐Ÿ˜‰ this attitude often makes me go very hard on myself though. neverending quest of achieving balance…

    i’m not alone most of the time but i don’t live with my family. i have a flatmate but we don’t cook together. so in terms of social pressure i’m in much easier position i guess. altough it’s always easier for me to refuse all food and not have a small piece just to fit in the situation. because, as you noticed, it’s a leak in the dam that produces a catastrophy.

    have you maybe tried to not eat at all on fasting days? i understood that you don’t feel well working fasted. and what about shifting ALL carbs to the last meal? i find this very convenient, prevents cravings during the day and brings a lot of satisfaction when in the evening you can have a nice, big meal.

Viewing 50 posts - 2,651 through 2,700 (of 3,046 total)

You must be logged in to reply.