Starting high protein/super low carb plan- 1 week test

Welcome to The Fast Diet The official Fast forums Body Different approaches to intermittent fasting
Starting high protein/super low carb plan- 1 week test

This topic contains 15 replies, has 4 voices, and was last updated by  fitnfast 9 years, 4 months ago.

Viewing 16 posts - 1 through 16 (of 16 total)

  • Since researching more about how our body’s use carbs, proteins and fats, I have decided to do a one week test of a very high protein, minimal fat, and very low carb eating plan.

    There is documented studies done that proved to be very beneficial for both weight loss and health. Feeling hungry has been a big problem for me on the fast days, and even though I can get through it most of the time, I really would like to find a way to feel more satiated.

    Also, my body obviously has extreme insulin and dairy sensitivity. Nine weeks into fasting, and I can very accurately predict weight gain, bloating, and digestive issues when I eat even a small amount of bread, crackers (even whole wheat), or milk and cheese. I am also on some pretty heavy duty pain medications, which I am sure affects how my body responds to food.

    I have still been losing weight, although I have seen it decline here and there, depending on what I eat.

    I also can’t stand the cravings I get! It makes me so mad at myself! I hate that out of control feeling. One of the benefits of a high protein diet is supposed to be less hunger and fewer cravings for sweets and starches.

    Yesterday, after my 17 hour fast, I ate 2 hard boiled eggs, then an apple (had some cheese too but that ends today!), and plain chicken for lunch. I wasn’t hungry again until dinner (I usually have a snack when I get home at 2 pm). For dinner, it was about 12 oz of steak (not an expensive cut!) fried in 1 T of oil. I must say, I was surprised at how I didn’t get hungry until around 2 am. Usually I don’t even make it to bedtime!

    I will post impressions and results as I go through the week. Maybe this can help someone else who is experiencing a slow down.

    Wow, I blew THAT one in a hurry!

    We fired a guy yesterday who had been a pain in our butts for months. It was just the last straw. So we ended up having a little celebration….in the shape of a pizza party! Thanks, guys! Ugh! Oh well, I will consider that a partial refeed day!

    Pizza was at 11 am, and I ate nothing else until 6, and that was just half a chicken breast.

    Moving on…..

    Week 1 results

    Actually, not quite a week, and even with the pizza, a candy bar on Wednesday, and only 1 half hour of exercise, I am down 1 lb.

    Some things I am going to change this week, besides the obvious no pizza, is I may broil instead of fry, and I bought olive oil to use instead of vegetable oil. Also, I may do more fish. But I really, REALLY was happy to lose all my carb cravings!

    Contrary to the beliefs of some, most all meat has some carbs, plus fat. This is not 100% protein, and I think it would be impossible to find cuts of meat that have no fat at all, unless maybe wild meat. I don’t know. But I feel fine, lost a lb, and worked 60 hours this week at a very physical job.

    So, I only cut out all breads, veggies, fruits except one apple a day. I did not count a calorie at all. Eggs and meats only, added cheese one day, and fried onions one day, so some carbs in those, though minimal. I am following the 16:8 fasting schedule, and didn’t use 5:2 or 4:3 at all. I may reincorporate these at some point. With work the way it is for the time being, this seems easier right now, and as long as I am losing and still healthy, I will keep with it.

    Hope everyone enjoys their days!

    Weigh in day for me, after a perfect, strict but easy full 5 days of nothing but meats and fats. No carbs at all except what is in the meat or fats. No fruit, no veggies. And am still doing 16:8.

    Results: down 3.2 lbs. No cravings at all, and my belly is flatter than it has been in 10 years!

    I have found my plan for life!

    Welldone, fit, was waiting to hear your results.

    Might join you soon, will need to do something really hard core, had pasta, chips, brownie, muesli, lots of wine and fried and poached fish on toast. Tastes so much better than it sounds.

    Not all at the same time, but loads of stuff I’ve been avoiding for months! Think I’ll call it a refeeding weekend.

    18,000 steps and not finished yet, though somehow I don’t think it will repair any of the damage.

    Bloody enjoyable though!

    Have you read the 4 hour body? Lots of tosh, I think, but some nuggets of sense, worth the read.

    But really chuffed for you!

    Holy cow! 18,000 steps?! You’re really going strong!

    I just had to do something drastic! I know some here think I am crazy but I think everybody has to experiment and find what works for them. Like Gary Raines said, every body processes nutrients differently. Some can eat lots of carbs and do good. Others not so much, and still others, not at all.

    I have seen all the women in my family suffer through diabetes, amputations, heart disease, dementia. I am breaking the cycle.

    I didn’t read that book. How was It (minus the obvious guy part!). Do you recommend it?

    20,000 steps yesterday! Though I had to walk up and down the hotel corridor last night to get the last few in, walking today. But knackered already.

    Still reading the book, will get back to you when I’m finished. The guy drinks wine and says it makes no difference to his regime, and I read the same thing in the papers the other day. Testing the theory this weekend lol!!!

    Fitnfast,

    Congratulations on your weight loss.

    Are you doing this diet every day? And planning on doing it long-term? Or will you revert to a more nutritionally balanced diet when you’ve lost weight and fixed your metabolism? I guess you must be taking a lot of supplements to get your nutrients?! As a woman in her 40s I’d be worried about increasing my risk of osteoporosis?

    And did you have your kidney function checked in advance?

    Could you provide the references for the documented studies that show long term health benefits? Most studies I’ve seen that talk about high protein diets don’t seem to be as extreme as yours (and do include other food groups), and I thought the jury was still out on long-term effects? I also thought very high protein blocks the regenerative effects of fasting?

    Sorry for all the questions! There’s just so much conflicting information/ opinion around.

    For info, I managed to get control of my carb cravings by cutting out bread, pasta, rice, added sugar. And I now eat less meat, and more vegetable protein, than I did pre-5:2. Not sure I could stomach all protein! Are you constipated? I think I would be!

    HI, Happynow. Thanks for your questions.

    First, I am planning on eating this way at least until I reach my goal, and maybe afterwards. It actually isn’t as unbalanced as you might think. Read up on it and you will be surprised. I know I was!

    There are numerous studies that have been done. I will list some physician names below, but the most well known is that of Stefanssons 12 month study after he returned from studying the Inuit tribe. Look up “Two brave men who ate nothing but meat for an entire year.”
    Other physicians who studied and then prescribed this to their patients (all of whom are referenced in “Good calories, Bad calories”:
    Dr. Blake Donaldson
    Dr. Robert Halsey
    Dr. Alfred Pennington
    Dr. George Gehrman of DuPont company..Good one
    Margarite Ohlson and Charlotte Young
    Look up any of these and you will see what they were doing.

    I am not constipated but might be if I didn’t already take a laxative to counteract my pain meds. I use the Butrans patch and tramadol for chronic back pain, both of which cause bowel troubles! So no problem there.

    I do take supplements, many of which I took before. I just increased amounts on some. Supplements are important even if just fasting.

    Osteoporosis? In my family? Nope.We actually have the opposite, hence the back issues (overgrowth of bone). No one in the immediate family has ever broken anything except for an ankle.

    I think I covered all your questions. If I missed anything, let me know.

    Now, as a final note, since I sense a little bit of “negativity” in your post; if you don’t want to eat this way, then don’t! You eat the way you want, it works for you, I’m thrilled for you! This works for me. I am in my 50’s, intelligent, healthier than all the men I work with and I do a very physical job (while they sit around stuffing their faces…And taking their heart meds!). I appreciate your concern, if that is what it is, but I suggest you spend your time and effort on YOU, not me.

    I did forget something…I had a massive amount of blood work done November last year, and will be repeating it in a few weeks. I will post results. All was normal, except slightly high cholesterol.

    Hi Fitnfast,

    Thanks for the speedy reply.

    I’m aware that native people like the Inuit (and American Indians, pre-white settlers) eat a diet largely comprised of animal products, and indeed get their carbohydrates/ fats/ essential nutrients from eating wild animals. But I understand there’s a world of difference between their diet and what I could source (industrially produced, factory farmed) from the local supermarket.

    My post wasn’t meant to be negative, just questioning, because I’m not familiar with the science/ research on this one. Thanks for providing me with some names to Google.

    On your last point, I’m afraid as I don’t know you my questions aren’t out of concern for you! I’m not that nice 🙂 We all make our own choices and take personal responsibility.

    I apologize sincerely. I guess I am little touchy since being blasted on another thread! Thank you for your interest and inquisitiveness. The more I read on the subject of obesity, the more fascinated I am by the human body and how it works!

    Hi Fit,

    No need to apologize. I came across a bit negative, you came across a bit defensive! That’s the joy of online forums…

    New Here….Interesting reads fitnfast…….Looking up info on a 16:8. Just starting the 5:2 today.

    Welcome, Fit! There is a massive amount of good info out there, and so many different ways to fast. Once you find (or create)one that works for you, the fat just melts off.

    I highly recommend reading the blogs at http://www.intensivedietarymanagement.com, and the “Good calories, Bad calories” book. Those two were life changing for me.

    Good luck to you!

    A quick weigh in this morning: down 1.6.

    Again, like happens to most of us, I started subconsciously adding too much of a good thing and therefore slowed the loss down, and corrected it at the last minute.

Viewing 16 posts - 1 through 16 (of 16 total)

You must be logged in to reply.