Losing too fast?

This topic contains 7 replies, has 7 voices, and was last updated by  Pattience 10 years, 2 months ago.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)

  • I started the the 5 and 2 a month ago…I’m eating 1100-1200 calories on feed days, and 500-600 on fast days. I eat lean proteins, veggies, fruit, and whole grains. I drink 90-100 ounces of water a day. I exercise moderately 2-3 days a week. I’ve lost 14 pounds in one month. I’m thrilled! I just have never lost weight so fast! Is is healthy for me?

    Here are my stats:

    Female age 40 height 5′ 9″
    Starting weight 190/current 176/goal 145-149

    Any insight would be appreciated 🙂

    I don’t know about too fast…I’m guessing everyone is different. But rapid weight loss can be just losing water weight – make sure you’re hydrated.
    I don’t know about your details (BMR, TDEE etc) but 1100-1200 calories seems like a VERY tiny amount for a person like you. My weight is similar to yours (currently 178, but I’m 5’4″)and even at a sedentary rate, my TDEE is about 1800 calories.
    In the long term, starving yourself will work against keeping the weight off. I keep reminding myself that the goal is to lose weight slowly and keep it off FOREVER.
    goood luck! 🙂

    From your stats you should be eating your TDEE @ 1839 calories per day on your feed days PrincessMelody:
    Because 1,200cals 5 days = 6,000cals + your 2x 500cal days all totals up to 7,000 cals for the week – Your week cals should total 10,195 so you are short changing your body of 3,195 calories. This is not a good way to do it, you should not be combining low cal diet with 5:2

    I think what’s important is if you will be able to keep the weight off in the long run. You seem to be only eating 900/1000 kcal a day. That seems very little since a regular caloric restriction diet doesn’t normally go under 1200/day. I’m just wondering if you’ll be able to keep this up. I know that for me, I’d be a lot more likely to give up after a while and start eating way too much again.

    Some people say you would end up in starvation mode, others believe this only happens if you undereat severely for an extensive amount of time (think hunger strikes and war prisoners). I don’t know enough about the subject to actually give an opinion on this (it’d be a wild stab in the dark) but I will say that the idea of Intermittent Fasting for most of us is finding a way of restricting our calorie intake in a way that is maintainable for the rest of our lives. I’m not sure that’s attainabe if you’re only eating 900 kcal/day.

    So I don’t know if it’s too little per se, but I’m think it might resemble a crash diet rather than a way of life, which is what this ‘diet’ is designed to be.

    Good luck with everything!

    Well done, that’s fantastic. I think if you need to lose nearly a quarter of your body weight then that’s the thing that you’re probably at most risk of health problems from, rather than losing weight too quickly to be honest. Your body can only sustain a certain amount of weight loss though, and I wouldn’t count on the rate of loss remaining the same obviously, but if you keep at it, you’ll be there by Christmas!

    Thank you all very much for the insight and information! I’m new to this, so you all are very helpful!

    I will reassess my daily calorie intake, as I do want to make this a lifestyle change…not just a temporary fix. Prior to starting this, I was on a 1200 calories a day plan, and I just added the two fast days to it. I have more work to do, and I truly appreciate all the help!! 🙂

    I don`t know what is fast what is not fast but every lose of weight is good result and your is very good for sure but that is my opinion………

    Ok use the TDEE calculator on this site. Read the faqs. For non-fast days, reduce your TDEE by no more than 500 but this much only if have a great deal to lose. My reduction from TDEE on non fast days is only 50. I have only about 7 more pounds/3kg to lose.

    While you are doing this, and any diet, maximise your nutrition along these lines.

    20g of protein each of 3 meals
    5 vegetables per day at 75 grams per serve
    2 fruit per day at 150g per serve
    between 30-50grams of fibre per day. Preferably 50 if you can get it up there. look up foods highest in fibre – these are beans lentils chickpeas.
    1 cup milk per day
    1 cup unsweetened yoghurt per day
    healthy fats- cold pressed extra virgin olive oil or other nut oils, nuts/seeds 30grams per day maximum, yellow cheese maximum 40g per day or white cheese i think its about half a cup. Don’t over restrict your healthy fats i.e. the oil. you can also use butter and cream but in moderation to match your calories.
    minimise processed and refined foods
    no more than 6tsp of sugar per day

    choose vegetables over bread, limit bread. choose whole grains most of the time when you do eat. don’t fill up on pasta and rice. fill up on vegetables.

    Cook your food.

    Fast days: try to go without food until you start to experience hunger which may be around lunchtime. Have a good healthy meal. A good healthy meal will keep you going for the rest of the day if necessary. I have found vegetables very sustaining on a fast day but i am now also eating more protein instead of vegetables to prevent muscle wasting but i can’t eat the recommended 50g per day.

    At breakfast time try to make do with a salt broth like vegemite broth, or miso, or stock cube. this will prevent headaches. Drink also plenty of water through the day. Headaches are caused by dehydration but you do need to have an adequate salt intake and when you fast you lose a lot of salt.

    I also have nescafe with milk but its better if i can leave this until later in the day and skip it at breakfast time.

Viewing 8 posts - 1 through 8 (of 8 total)

You must be logged in to reply.