Help for a beginner

This topic contains 10 replies, has 7 voices, and was last updated by  Jcunningham264 6 years, 7 months ago.

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)

  • Hallo. I am new to 5:2 dieting so I have the following questions:

    1. what can you drink on fast days? Obviously water but what about tea or coffee?

    2. Over what sort of timeframe are you supposed to do 5:2? A month, three months, six months?

    Thanks in advance!

    Hi H and welcome:

    You can drink anything you want – just count the calories if there are any. Tea and coffee are fine.

    If you really do 5:2, you will find it turns into a way of life. People that have lost 50 or 100 pounds report they just continue doing 5:2 – perhaps eating more on their non-diet days or setting a ‘range’ where, if they exceed the top causes them to do 5:2 until they return their desired weight.

    Here are some tips: https://thefastdiet.co.uk/forums/topic/the-basics-for-newbies-your-questions-answered/

    Good Luck!

    I drink mostly tea with a dash of skimmed milk & water… I count the 100 ml of milk as 40 cals..I only have a dash in tea….. Also Coca cola zero is good in fact anything with zero calories.I have no time frame… weight loss is an ongoing thing… you’ll know when you need to maintain when you get to the weight you want to be
    Good luck 🙂

    @hbox1983 – I prefer to eat my calories on fast days so drink black coffee, black herbal teas, Marmite tea (yum) and sometimes low cal fizzy drinks in the evening if I am desperate. I have a feeling artificial sweeteners may interfer with your insulin/blood sugar control but there seems to be little concensus on this.

    On timing, you can fast for health and do it indefinately. Lots are fasting for weight loss and do 2 to 3 fast days a week until they reach their goal weight. Most people with a weight problem will gain back lost weight over time unless they radically change their approach to eating so some people fast long term for 1 to 2 days a week to prevent weight gain. Hope that helps.

    Hbox, Fasting is a Lifestyle and it is for life. We have been Fasting 2 days/week for 5 years. No time limit.

    I drink ice water, herbal tea, cafe au lait at breakfast, 8 oz milk at lunch [need the Calcium], sparkling water, and a glass of wine with dinner [but that is because I’m Maintaining my weight, not trying to lose it] When you get below your Target Weight, you can drink what you wish.

    Happy Fast Day.

    I read recently that the two Fast days could be back to back. Are there benefits to this over non consecutive Fast days?

    Most people choose Fast Days based on their own schedule. We like Mon + Thurs. Some do back to back. If we have a ‘can’t miss’ event on a Thursday, we’ll Fast on Wednesday instead. No special benefits as to the days you choose.

    Thanks for that. I will probably settle on Monday and Thursday too.

    See you Monday.

    I agree with fasting_me “Fasting is a Lifestyle and it is for life.” – don’t just think of it as a “diet” – it’s much more than that – the Moseley book outlines many different advantages and research is unveiling more.

    My tea drinking habits are unchanged. I very rarely drink coffee – I like a big coffee house coffee about once or twice a month if I am out and want to treat myself (but not on a fasting day – a big milky cappuccino is something like 300 cals!) i don’t like coffee as it (imho) makes your breath smell. I drink Earl Gray tea (Twinnings or co-op is the best imho) and lemon and ginger tea. I have never drank any kind of fizzy drink – i.e. Coke, or fruit juice or squash. I also drink hot water – just a weaker version of Earl Gray!)

    FYI I started 16th Jan at 90.1kg and I’ve been bobbling around my target weight or 84kg for about a week at 84.1-84.4kg – so that’s 6.1kg = 13.5 pounds – very nearly a stone. I will continue with 5:2 for a while after just to see what happens but I’m happy with where I am now – I think fasting will always be part of my life – it’s a tool – something I’ve learned how to do and how to use and I know I can do it any time I want – I’ll continue with it (5:2 or 6:1 or whatever) for the many health benefits. I chose 84kg because that was lowest weight I ever was in the last 4 years of my life as a regular runner (100+ runs a year, 600+ miles a year as a minimum) (I have weighed myself and measured my blood pressure regularly over the years and kept records). HTH

    Thanks Lemonstar. I am loving it so far. This is my second week and I’ve lost 5lbs and 18cm, I’m thrilled. I have decided to eat only one meal at dinner time about 5.30. Here’s to feeling lighter.

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)

You must be logged in to reply.