Just Starting – A Quick Question

This topic contains 4 replies, has 4 voices, and was last updated by  sylvestra 10 years, 10 months ago.

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)

  • Ok, so i have read the book and it does make sense but i dont understand how i can loose weight on fast days if i’m still eating. I last had a meal at 7pm last night and have decided not to eat again now until 7pm this evening which makes it a full 24 hrs. Is this right? Do i have to eat my 500 calaroies or can i just have a piece of fruit at some point through the day when the hunger gets really bad. I am drinking plenty of fluid but not tea or coffee as i dont want to have any milk today. Its now coming up to 1pm, lunch time, and i’m feeling ok but dont know if i can last until 7pm this evening with nothing at all. If i eat something now, will i have wasted my time, even though i have not eaten for 18 hrs. Help i’m a little confused.

    Oh dear!

    There are many variations between what individuals do but the basic 5:2 works like this:

    1)Have your evening meal the night before your fastday
    2)Wake up the next day and spread your 500 calories throughout this waking day however you choose (some eat 1 500 calorie meal towards the end of the day, some have 3 tiny meals – whatever suits you)
    3)Go to bed having only eaten 500 calories

    Do this 2 days during the week – That’s it.

    Some people do just do a 24 hour ‘genuine’ fast and then eat a normal meal (not restricting to 500 cals) sometimes that works but most people will be realistically doing 36 hours ish in reality.

    Hi Colette,

    You can eat your 500 hundred whenever you like it all depends on the individual. In my case I finish eating on Sunday any time up until around 8pm and the next time I eat is on Monday (my fast day) at around 2pm when I have soup for 150 calories. Then I will have dinner around 7pm or 7.30pn which is usually a chicken or prawn stir fry. The main thing is not to go mad on the days you are not fasting – just stick to your normal day of around 1600 – 2000 calories and you will be fine.

    Good luck 🙂

    Hi Colette…you will lose weight because on fast days your calorie intake is much reduced – approx 25% of your normal eating. If you go to the ‘how?’ link at the top of the page you will see another link (BMR/TDEE). In there you will see what these acronyms mean and an explanation of why you need to know. There is also a calculator to establish your own levels.

    The main thing on fast days it to try not to obsess about food. What you think of as hunger is usually thirst and a cup of black coffee/tea or a glass of water will sort them out. There is no need to miss out on coffee or tea on fast days provided you use part of your 500 cal allowance for the milk etc. 5:2 is not about denying yourself that’s what make it so sustainable.

    As for when to eat on fast days, it’s a case of trying things to see what fits.Just make sure you have NO MORE THAN 500 calories total on your fast day including drinks (you don’t have to use all 500, I don’t). Some people have 3 small meals – a fast from dinner the previous evening until breakfast (12 hours), some people have lunch and dinner (18 hour fast) and some, like me, do dinner until dinner of 500 cals (24 hour fast) and yet others wait until breakfast on their next fast day (36 hour fast). Some do dinner to dinner, others lunch to lunch. There is no ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ way. This way of eating should fit round you and your lifestyle, it shouldn’t take over your life. If you can’t fast on a planned day, no problem, do it another day. If you start fasting and then something happens to upset the plan…do it another day.
    If what you’re doing today doesn’t work for you… do a different way next time.

    On your non fast days the ideal is to eat at a level BETWEEN your BMR and your TDEE. No foods are ‘forbidden’ – you can eat WHAT you want just NOT HOW MUCH you want.

    t takes a little while to get used to this new way of eating but it becomes second nature after a while.

    Good luck

    xx

    Just reading through your post again…if you had a normal dinner last night and nothing until dinner tonight then tonight’s dinner should have no more than your 500 cal fast day allowance. If you eat 500 throughout the day and then have a ‘normal’ dinner, you will not have had a fast day.

    If you have,say, 100 cals at lunchtime today then you will have 400 cals left for dinner tonight.

    xx

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)

You must be logged in to reply.