Welcome to The Fast Diet › The official Fast forums › Fast Exercise › Getting fit › Exercise Is Dangerous For Your Diet
This topic contains 112 replies, has 47 voices, and was last updated by dykask 1 year, 9 months ago.
Viewing 14 posts - 101 through 114 (of 114 total)
11 Sep 16
Has anyone considered that we are not actually after weight loss, we are actually after fat loss and better health? And if that is the case, stop relying on the scale. I use a measuring tape, pictures and the way my clothes fit as an indicator. I think telling people not to work out because they won’t “lose weight” is not telling the whole story.
It is true that you can lose weight on diet alone, and it is also true that exercise alone will not necessarily yield weight loss. However, when you have muscle composition you burn more calories in a resting state. Also,there have been studies that directly link heart and brain health. There are even claims that physical activity can fight alzheimers. I think it is irresponsible to tell people to throw out physical activity because of what some number on a scale might say. Scales do not tell the whole story. For instance, I work out six days a week. Sometimes I do two a days. I freaking love love love fitness. I run, cycle, lift weights and do HIIT, circuit training and kickboxing. Keeping a varied routine keeps me motivated! Anyway point is, I gained three pounds. If I were only relying on the scale I would have given up and gotten all woe is me, but I pulled out a measuring tape and saw that I had lost another half inch in my waist! Muscle does not way more thab fat but it is more dense and you can gain muscle at the same rate you are losing fat. Also, when you are building muscle the little tears in muscles can cause inflimmation which causes the scale to move up. So, screw the scale! Embrace a healthy lifestyle in all of its’ forms and remember that we don’t wear our pounds on our clothes for the world to see. It is just a number!
Some people truly enjoy exercise as well. And how would you know if you are one or not of you have never tried? Don’t rob people of that experience by throwing the baby out with the bath water.
Oh also, yes exercise does make you more hungry (it can rather) but on the 5 2 fast your caloric needs are your maintenence calories and are adjusted to your activity level. Mine is 2300 so I really have a shit load of wiggle room. This fast seems like the perfect companion for working out if you look at it like that
There is absolutely nothing wrong with exercise. There are huge benefits to be had in exercising. I walk and/or ride my bike every day. However if you are 300 pounds and can barely walk let alone do exercise then realistically modifying your diet so that you eat less is your best option rather than exercising more. Your aim is to run at a caloric deficit. You can achieve this by eating the same amount and increasing your expenditure (exercising) or keeping expenditure the same and reducing caloric intake.
12 Sep 16
Hi L and welcome:
As you read my post, you will recognize this quotation: “Let me first say that exercise is without doubt the number one thing you can do to improve your health – even above weight loss.”
And I did not tell people ‘not to work out because they won’t lose weight’. What I did say was this: “If you must exercise, at least don’t blame your slow or nonexistent weight loss on 5:2, and quit! Your exercise is helping you become more healthy, and 5:2 is helping you lose fat weight. You just have to be patient and wait for the slow acting 5:2 to overwhelm the effects of your exercise!
It seems you agree with me!
13 Oct 16
Very late to this party …
While I’m sure one of the links posted probably talks about this and maybe everyone knows about it, but exercise can also make you lazy when you aren’t exercising. To some extent people trade activity. Exercise is still really good to do it just may make you sleep more and move less outside of it.
The little things like, eating a bit more, moving a bit less and replacing a bit of fat with a bit of muscle can really add up. This can cause one to really be confused about what is going on.
I’m in my forth stage of getting in control of my body weight.
Stage 1: 106kg & waist ~125cm (Never really measured it.)
(Action) – improved my diet, ate less did almost daily Tabata style workouts less than 20mins
(Result) – 92kg & waist @ 109cm in about a year, ALWAYS HUNGRY
Stage 2: 92kg 109cm
(Action) – running, push-ups, pull-ups, jumping, biking 600kc to 1000kc / day. Kept improving diet.
(Result) – 94kg 106cm after 2 years. Gained 2kg and lost 3cm around waist. Always HUNGRY
Stage 3: 94kg 106cm
(Action) – On a whim I cut deserts, and then most refined sugar in diet. Added in healthy fats. Also realized I could workout some before eating and live.
(Result) – 86kg 87cm in 4 months!!!!!! Turns out I’m a little sensitive to sugar. I also lost my hunger and started trying skipping a meal here and there. Once I hit that level I stopped losing weight.
Stage 4: 86kg 87cm (After about 2 months of being stuck)
(Action) – 5:2 (no eating on fast days) Switch to sprint 8 workouts 3 days a week. (HIIT 8 reps 30 seconds each at max)
(Result) – 83kg 85cm … less than a month so far. Still not hungry! 🙂
So excise is hard on the fat but the numbers don’t always show that.
BTW – I’m loving 5:2 and hating HIIT. Thankfully only 3 workouts a week. I’m not crying by the end of the workout, but I want too …
I’m with you L. A misleading and ill-judged thread at best. Exercise benefits FAR outweigh (if you forgive the pun….) the fact that a number on a scale doesn’t move as you’d hoped.
21 Nov 16
I think that misinformation is easy to pass off as real, and as such, can lead others astray.
The bottom line:
Exercise improves the fitness and size of muscles – Not only does exercise burn calories in the process of performing the exercise, but it also DEVELOPS and INCREASES the fitness and mass (size) of muscles …. Increased muscle mass = INCREASED BMI – Your basic metabolism is increased, which will help you reduce fat storage EVERY DAY, fasting or not …. Muscle development is the only means I know of to increase your basal metabolism ….
Whether working out or laying on your back – increased muscle mass burns calories at a higher rate than muscles that are NOT exercised.
When trying to meet your fast day goals, physical exercise will help you keep excess calories from ruining your fast …. Eat a little too much ? …. Walk for a while and reduce the impact.
My primary goals have been to 1) Lose fat and 2) Increase muscular fitness.
After losing 100 LBS and spending 1.5 years lifting weights – My body composition has completely changed. Where I was obese and disgusted, I am now much leaner and happier …
Exercise does not harm …. It greatly helps in my view …
29 Nov 16
This research referenced earlier in this thread is interesting:
The research suggested that, in the study, exercise alone had a relatively small impact on weight loss, that alternate day fasting had 3 times the effect, and that the combination of alternate day fasting and exercise had 6 times the effect.
Perhaps exercise increases the urge to eat to build up muscle? And the combination of exercise and fasting puts added pressure on burning fat stores?
I’m happy that I focused first on dietary change, as Simon said, and after that was bedded down, I added exercise.
28 Dec 16
When you are on the 5:2 fast diet, you need to abstain from too much of exercise. Something like a walk everyday and light exercises are enough for you to lose weight and stay healthy.
5 Jan 17
You must keep realistic expectations from your exercise. Some people think that all they have to do is workout and they can eat whatever they want, but there is not an iota of truth in there. You need to combine the two diet and exercise to make weight loss an reality. Also, when you exercise you become really hungry and to cope with that hunger you end up eating more and than you should and you don’t lose weight.
9 Jan 17
Stating the obvious – any exercise of any kind is beneficial for your health: http://www.foxnews.com/health/2017/01/09/its-all-good-any-exercise-cuts-risk-death-study-finds.html
11 Feb 17
Yet another study showing exercise is not important for weight loss and diet is the critical factor: http://www.msn.com/en-us/health/healthtrending/exercise-is-not-the-secret-to-weight-loss/ar-AAmJZcE?li=AA5LBhu&ocid=spartandhp
Don’t believe you can’t lose weight if you can’t/won’t exercise. You can. You just need to eat less to lose weight.
5:2 causes you to eat less. It is really that simple. Don’t make it harder!
23 Aug 18
Thank You, Thank You, Thank You, I was just ready to give up my ADF, because i was exercising and still not losing weight fast enough. Now it not only makes it clear as to why it’s taking so long but i feel so encouraged to continue. You have given me hope so that i will continue exercising for my health. My first thought this morning was to double-up on my exercise and just give up the ADF. I now have a path to follow with encouragement from you.
25 Aug 18
Exercise may be hard on the weight loss but not exercising is harder on one’s health.
The thing is the number on the scale isn’t as important as being trim and fit. If you are trying to lose fat, the combination of fasting, exercise and healthy diet will do wonders. Exercise doesn’t always help one lose weight, but it can help one to lose fat.
I don’t think calorie restriction is the way to go through with exercise, I had horrible problems with that when combined with hard exercise. However eating healthy which can mostly be done by avoiding food that has added refined sugars added to them has worked wonders with exercise. Partly because one ends up eating foods that have high nutritional value. Focus on nutrition if you are exercising.
Basically the theme of this thread seems wrong. It isn’t the exercise that is an issue it is the bad diets that people try to hold on to.
You must be logged in to reply.
Username or Email:
Track your weight and measurements, BMI and TDEE with our new tracker.
The Fast books are available throughout the world and in many different languages. Buy a copy today.
Michael is touring Australia this September! Here's a link to dates and tickets. Hope to see you there.
Michael Mosley gives an update for 2019, current research in the field and announces a tour starting in February.
Michael looks at the Horizon special, "What's the Right Diet for You" and tells us which diet they say is best for him.
• All featured posts •
in Weight loss • updated 40 seconds ago by Emma Taylor
in Weight loss • updated 5 minutes ago by symba7
in Welcome to The Fast Diet and Exercise forums • updated 2 hours, 38 minutes ago by LJoyce
• All recent topics •
Copyright © 2020 Michael Mosley and Mimi Spencer
Technical questions or problems with the site? Please email our technical contact.